Movies

Aristus

(68,357 posts)

56. The one reassuring thing about the depiction of the battle on Omaha Beach

Thu Mar 27, 2014, 03:14 PM

Mar 2014

is that that was as bad as it got on D-Day.

The assault on Utah Beach took far fewer casualites, and got inland much quicker. The British came ashore on Gold and Sword Beaches riding bicycles and playing bagpipes. The Canadians at Juno Beach had it tough, but managed to complete all of their assigned objectives by the end of the first day.

Something the film couldn't depict, though, was the fact that the assault on Omaha Beach actually went on for the whole day, and part of the next. That might have been too awful to watch, though. Both SPR and The Longest Day depicted the troops getting the better of the German defenders within a couple of hours.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

82 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Most graphically disturbing movies? [View all] clarice Feb 2014 OP

The Cook, The Thief, The Wife and her Lover I found particularly disturbing.... NRaleighLiberal Feb 2014 #1

I've seen both.... clarice Feb 2014 #2

My then teenage daughter nearly lost it - uncontrollable sobbing. thought of 2 more... NRaleighLiberal Feb 2014 #3

I must admit.... clarice Feb 2014 #4

Not a dry eye... cactusfractal Feb 2014 #5

The one reassuring thing about the depiction of the battle on Omaha Beach Aristus Mar 2014 #56

Indeed, the beginning of SPR made me feel like I had PTSD. arcane1 Feb 2014 #6

The final siege battle scene of Platoon is just incredible... NRaleighLiberal Feb 2014 #7

A pair of shorts from the Animatrix... Chan790 Feb 2014 #8

When I was a teen in the 1960s, it was the horror film Blood Feast aint_no_life_nowhere Feb 2014 #9

This is a classic...sort of. nt clarice Feb 2014 #14

What a fantastic poster! Susannah Elf Apr 2015 #64

A Clockwork Orange OmahaBlueDog Feb 2014 #10

+1 on this JustAnotherGen Feb 2014 #42

Maybe there's something wrong with me. I can remember those scenes, & I remember being scarletwoman Feb 2014 #43

I felt the same way. Susannah Elf Apr 2015 #60

Lot's of good ones....thanks for your responses. clarice Feb 2014 #11

I've seen it mockmonkey Feb 2014 #12

I know..right? absolutely brutal. Can't unsee it. nt clarice Feb 2014 #13

I'll second "The Cook, The THief..." sweetloukillbot Feb 2014 #15

I'll third it. I still get queasy... WorseBeforeBetter Mar 2014 #55

For me it was Susannah Elf Apr 2015 #61

Yeah, that was nauseating. WorseBeforeBetter Apr 2015 #63

The ending scene of "Looking for Mr. Goodbar"... MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #16

I saw that movie *shudder* nt clarice Feb 2014 #17

Yeah, you know what I mean, clarice! MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #19

DON"T link it...eeek.....lol clarice Feb 2014 #23

She wasn't stabbed by Richard Gere! TexasBushwhacker Feb 2014 #20

Yeah… that's right... MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #22

That's right....I forgot. nt clarice Feb 2014 #24

Not graphically.... ProudToBeBlueInRhody Feb 2014 #18

Yes it IS. nt clarice Feb 2014 #25

Reservoir Dogs TexasBushwhacker Feb 2014 #21

Me too.... clarice Feb 2014 #26

My mother saw Psycho in 1960 TexasBushwhacker Feb 2014 #29

Yikes !!!! nt clarice Feb 2014 #32

The blood was actually Bosco. valerief Feb 2014 #36

Didn't know that...great trivia question. Thanks. nt clarice Feb 2014 #37

At this point in Tarantino's career Susannah Elf Apr 2015 #62

Tetsuo the Iron Man and Cannibal Holocaust come to mind. nt ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #27

Now you're getting hard core. lol clarice Feb 2014 #28

Damn, just when I'd forgotten about Tetsuo, you had to bring it up! nt valerief Feb 2014 #35

I have seen that movie so many times. ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #39

I just checked your profile. Male. Of course. It's too "holy shit, no!" for us females. :) nt valerief Feb 2014 #40

Tetsuo the Iron Man is too "holy shit" for most people. ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #41

Salo? nt clarice Feb 2014 #44

I love that movie. ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #45

cool. nt clarice Feb 2014 #47

Men Behind the Sun? nt clarice Feb 2014 #48

Ha! I own that one too. ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #49

You are one sick puppy. *wink* clarice Feb 2014 #50

I know. Being sick, creepy fuck is fun. nt ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #52

A Serbian Film? It's the worst. nt clarice Feb 2014 #51

I am surprised no one has said Eraserhead yet. ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #30

absolutely !!! That baby ! nt clarice Feb 2014 #33

The Fly, specifically the birth scene Little_Wing Feb 2014 #31

yup !!! nt clarice Feb 2014 #34

Gummo ! weirrrrrrd. nt clarice Feb 2014 #38

^^^this^^^ valerief Feb 2014 #46

I refuse to watch that shit. Manifestor_of_Light Feb 2014 #53

The Human Centipede? Amerincorporated Feb 2014 #54

Jacob's Ladder AwakeAtLast Oct 2014 #57

I have a tie decision AtomicKitten Jan 2015 #58

Interesting that you mentioned a Korean movie davidpdx Sep 2015 #80

My secret shame is horror movies. AtomicKitten Sep 2015 #81

I liked horror movies when I was 10-12 davidpdx Sep 2015 #82

Deep Throat - LOL - I ran out of the theater LeftInTX Apr 2015 #59

The most powerful and horrific film ever made is Night and Fog .. 32 minutes of death Stuart G Apr 2015 #65

Yep, that one's really bleak! Independent_Liberal May 2015 #74

Requiem for a Dream, the director's cut. NuclearDem Apr 2015 #66

A Serbian Film Islandurp May 2015 #67

YIKES. nt clarice May 2015 #68

Subtle is better Zippyjuan May 2015 #69

My scariest XxShelbersxX May 2015 #70

Yup pretty &^&^ing scary !!!! Welcome to DU. nt clarice May 2015 #71

For those who don't understand why some of us like graphically disturbing and upsetting films... Independent_Liberal May 2015 #72

Speaking of disturbing films, has anyone seen the British film Threads from 1984? Independent_Liberal May 2015 #73

Yes, I've seen it. Very bleak, very disturbing. Guaranteed to ruin your day. nt clarice May 2015 #75

Audition. bvf Jun 2015 #76

eeek eeeek eeeek . nt clarice Jun 2015 #77

If someone already mentioned it and I missed it I apologize. Juicy_Bellows Aug 2015 #78

Yes it is....one of my favorites... BUT a very harrowing experience. nt clarice Aug 2015 #79