Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

biophile

(1,090 posts)
22. Definitely not a libertarian or anti-vax; no ax to grind
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 08:34 AM
10 hrs ago

But in the realm of healthcare there is always a trade-off in terms of public good vs. public cost. Having worked in medicine, I saw tremendous waste of resources and funds. Not so much in vaccine administration, but the Hep B shot is probably the one - maybe only example- of an inefficient way to use a vaccine for public health good. I call myself vaccine hesitant- I got the Covid vaccine but only after it had been out for a while and was finally FDA approved. By then I could see which one had the fewest side effects as well.
My dog and horse and cats get the vaccines they need. (My indoor cats do not get all of them as they are not exposed to certain diseases, but the outdoor cats will get more).
The most egregious waste of Medicare funds is in elder care, not vaccines. But there is an incredible profit motive at work in vaccines and pharmaceuticals, so that is a problem and needs to be considered. I guess I’m essentially a pragmatic person who is not sentimental about prolonging life at any cost. I believe in providing comfort and pain remediation but nursing homes and hospitals will definitely pad the billing for unneeded treatments or services, simply because they can bill Medicare.
Anyway, please know that just because a person is not keen on a certain vaccine, it doesn’t make them anti-vax. I was going to get the Zostavax years ago for shingles at age 57 but insurance didn’t cover it and it was about $250. I read the package insert and realized that its efficiency was roughly 60% for my age group so I decided not to pay for a near coin toss. The new one - Shingrix- is much more effective- I can recommend that one.
So I hope you can find it in your heart to see that I am not advocating for a libertarian hellscape, but a reasonable approach to healthcare where decisions are based on medical need, personal circumstances, public good, relative risk and valid scientific evidence.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Illinois has enacted snowybirdie Yesterday #1
Parents should demand their pediatricians follow the Illinois vaccination schedule. FarPoint Yesterday #3
There are a couple "regional" health alliances/colaboratives BumRushDaShow Yesterday #5
And yet he might be right about this one. TheRickles Yesterday #2
Agree on this one vaccine- totally unnecessary unless the mother was at risk as a drug abuser biophile Yesterday #4
So, your theory is that you can perfectly identify a subgroup of babies which ought to be given protection? xocetaceans Yesterday #10
No, it's not for me personally to decide biophile Yesterday #12
To be clearer, my post indicates that the knowledge a person needs to have in order to carry out what you seem . . . xocetaceans 17 hrs ago #21
Definitely not a libertarian or anti-vax; no ax to grind biophile 10 hrs ago #22
Some HepB + mothers aren't tested. Or they have false-negative results. mainer Yesterday #6
Asian Americans are at higher risk. deurbano Yesterday #7
So, your theory is that you can perfectly identify a subgroup of babies which ought to be given protection? What . . . xocetaceans Yesterday #8
Utter hogwash. You don't know what you're talking about. PSPS Yesterday #13
Wait a minute... maybe I misunderstood you... slightlv Yesterday #16
What damage does giving every baby the Hep B vaccine cause? NickB79 21 hrs ago #20
I should say that Magatry is a murder-suicide cult. ananda Yesterday #9
I think waiting till babies are older is a good idea womanofthehills Yesterday #11
Oh, please. The liver damage can already be happeinig before babies "are older." PSPS Yesterday #14
Fevers are scary. But they are only one indicator in a myriad of symptoms used to diagnose problems. ... littlemissmartypants Yesterday #17
U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is a baby killer. nt SunSeeker Yesterday #15
So which ones will need it then? mdbl Yesterday #18
In a brutal week for public health, the chairman on the Senate health committee could act. So why doesn't he? https://bs LetMyPeopleVote 22 hrs ago #19
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»US vaccine advisers say n...»Reply #22