Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Greece wants $236 billion in German World War II reparations [View all]freshwest
(53,661 posts)46. They behave as if they are self-sufficient though. I suggest it's their reluctance to fight with...
whatever version of Koch types they've had going on there for some time.
But they shouldn't be let off the hook if they took the money at fair terms. Because allegedly (as I said, not European) that money came from the pockets of the Germans, et al, in the EU who work and pay in high taxes, and weren't part of the Third Reich nor did they benefit from it.
AFAIK, the allegation that 'debt is a scam' is based on the idea the Allies didn't have billions of dollars of debt from WW2. That's just wishful thinking, we're still paying for the damn thing. We nearly lost the war and as I've stated before after watching Ken Burns' Roosevelt series and reading up on it, FDR had to go to the money men and the oligarchs he called out with the much vaunted 'I welcome their hatred' quote. He saw that the USA was in danger of losing to Germany, and had to 'beg' them for help. They created the industrial production line that literally pulverized the Third Reich as they mobilized under FDR's leadership. Some anarchists say it wouldn't matter who won the war. I beg to differ.
IMO, there's scant difference in the utopia that Hitler thought he was creating and what ISIS is proposing. It was a utopian vision that met Ayn Rand's standards, with the Supermen ruling over disposable humanity and ISIS is the same animal as they seek to build their empire.
Because imperialism and empire don't have to be under the control of classical aristocrats as some idealogues would have us believe. Nor is it the vision of only the West. The meme that is anti-Western and anti-American is Exceptionalism rearing its ugly head. The world knew how to Empire, long before the British Empire was a gleam in some bloodline patriarch's eye.
It's the effect, not the label. What we see paraded as being the socialist label has no magic with me now, and I am a life long social democrat and think capitalism is a wasteful, immoral system. Yet in more than one case, we see the ones who say they are liberators are just scamming the people by telling them what they want to hear with words and stealing from them behind their backs like Putin. It is the Westerners who are most likely to fall for this, believing Communism was a change for people. It just transferred the wealth into other hands, although the dream persists that it really is the way to Equality. It was built on blood like every other empire was.
That was veering far off topic and not well expressed. However, the Greek 'moral' argument may hold weight within a world paradigm where those who lost wealth to empires like the Third Reich, are demanding they be repaid.
What I don't get is why, after all the talk, they are even in the EU. I fear the Greeks have bought into something that still isn't going to help, but is the same thing, under a new name.
All that being said, I don't think nations, any nation, lend to others out of altruism unless there are layers of that in play to keep from having another war. I think the USA and West has attempted to bribe its way out of having another WW2, or WW3. It may be that war is more the natural state than not.
These loans were not gifts. The nations that caterwauled about the Iraq War but lent money to the USA for it were expecting something in return. China is also getting ahead in different regions, none of their 'aid' is done out of love. And that is no slam on them, as they take from their own people to buy influence with other nations and expect a return for it.
I need more coffee or sleep, not sure which.
But they shouldn't be let off the hook if they took the money at fair terms. Because allegedly (as I said, not European) that money came from the pockets of the Germans, et al, in the EU who work and pay in high taxes, and weren't part of the Third Reich nor did they benefit from it.
AFAIK, the allegation that 'debt is a scam' is based on the idea the Allies didn't have billions of dollars of debt from WW2. That's just wishful thinking, we're still paying for the damn thing. We nearly lost the war and as I've stated before after watching Ken Burns' Roosevelt series and reading up on it, FDR had to go to the money men and the oligarchs he called out with the much vaunted 'I welcome their hatred' quote. He saw that the USA was in danger of losing to Germany, and had to 'beg' them for help. They created the industrial production line that literally pulverized the Third Reich as they mobilized under FDR's leadership. Some anarchists say it wouldn't matter who won the war. I beg to differ.
IMO, there's scant difference in the utopia that Hitler thought he was creating and what ISIS is proposing. It was a utopian vision that met Ayn Rand's standards, with the Supermen ruling over disposable humanity and ISIS is the same animal as they seek to build their empire.
Because imperialism and empire don't have to be under the control of classical aristocrats as some idealogues would have us believe. Nor is it the vision of only the West. The meme that is anti-Western and anti-American is Exceptionalism rearing its ugly head. The world knew how to Empire, long before the British Empire was a gleam in some bloodline patriarch's eye.
It's the effect, not the label. What we see paraded as being the socialist label has no magic with me now, and I am a life long social democrat and think capitalism is a wasteful, immoral system. Yet in more than one case, we see the ones who say they are liberators are just scamming the people by telling them what they want to hear with words and stealing from them behind their backs like Putin. It is the Westerners who are most likely to fall for this, believing Communism was a change for people. It just transferred the wealth into other hands, although the dream persists that it really is the way to Equality. It was built on blood like every other empire was.
That was veering far off topic and not well expressed. However, the Greek 'moral' argument may hold weight within a world paradigm where those who lost wealth to empires like the Third Reich, are demanding they be repaid.
What I don't get is why, after all the talk, they are even in the EU. I fear the Greeks have bought into something that still isn't going to help, but is the same thing, under a new name.
All that being said, I don't think nations, any nation, lend to others out of altruism unless there are layers of that in play to keep from having another war. I think the USA and West has attempted to bribe its way out of having another WW2, or WW3. It may be that war is more the natural state than not.
These loans were not gifts. The nations that caterwauled about the Iraq War but lent money to the USA for it were expecting something in return. China is also getting ahead in different regions, none of their 'aid' is done out of love. And that is no slam on them, as they take from their own people to buy influence with other nations and expect a return for it.
I need more coffee or sleep, not sure which.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
57 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Well, you don't really need to be an economist to see what would happen.
Nuclear Unicorn
Feb 2015
#43
They behave as if they are self-sufficient though. I suggest it's their reluctance to fight with...
freshwest
Feb 2015
#46
Ukraine may want reparations from Russia one day. Don't hold your breath, guys.
pampango
Feb 2015
#2
That is interesting. I knew about the reparations paid in the 1950's but not the 2009 request.
pampango
Feb 2015
#17
I remember from something in the 60s talking about it and they paid us everything they owed.
jwirr
Feb 2015
#16
Okay I am wrong but not totally. At Potsdam in 1945 it was decided that Germany would pay
jwirr
Feb 2015
#32
Ha! that was unexpected. Sort of a brilliant off-footing move. Now the Germans have to
Warren Stupidity
Feb 2015
#3
Which is why those appearing before the EU with hat in hand and pockets out-turned
Nuclear Unicorn
Feb 2015
#8
Good for them and I hope they also start going after their Crooked Bankers and Politicians
sabrina 1
Feb 2015
#6
A meme which needs repeating: "Economic Terrorist" (taken from Economic Hit Man?)
2banon
Feb 2015
#20
How much guilt do present-day German taxpayers bear for the deeds of the Nazis?
Nye Bevan
Feb 2015
#7
I was wrong see post 32. I looked on the a site called War Reparations and learned that we did not
jwirr
Feb 2015
#48
Restorative Justice would be the guilty paying for their own misdeeds. What is being described here
Nuclear Unicorn
Feb 2015
#44