Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: Someone sent me the video of Bernie's hour-long town hall in Wisconsin [View all]Madam45for2923
(7,178 posts)24. I agree it's so bizarre people denying blatant in your face racism!
Garrett78 (2,657 posts)
Someone sent me the video of Bernie's hour-long town hall in Wisconsin
And this was my reaction:
Okay, I'm 11 minutes in and not sure I can take much more. Bernie's dismissal of the role racism (as well as sexism) played in this election is highly irritating. And he's simply wrong when he suggests most Trump supporters aren't bigots. As Ta-Nehisi Coates points out, "Studying the 2016 election, the political scientist Philip Klinkner found that the most predictive question for understanding whether a voter favored Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump was Is Barack Obama a Muslim?'
And make no mistake, xenophobia and anti-Muslim sentiment is racism at the root. Birtherism is racism at the root.
Not to mention the 25+ years of hatred that victimized Clinton. An article on that: "The deep disgust for Hillary Clinton..."
Clinton, of course, is white, but - as Coates points out - Democrats are associated with being on the side of people who aren't white. And the white backlash has been building for the last 8 years. Survey after survey demonstrates that *many* Trump supporters subscribe to bigoted beliefs.
Then there's the FBI's interference, Russian hacking and a pathetic mainstream media (ratings-focused obsession with spectacle, and promotion of false equivalencies in the name of some twisted sense of what constitutes "balance" . An article on the media that I highly recommend: http://www.newsweek.com/neil-buchanan-cruel-crooked-caricature-doomed-clinton-520125
And, last but not least, voter suppression enabled by the Shelby County v. Holder decision of 2013. An article on its effects: https://thinkprogress.org/2016-a-case-study-in-voter-suppression-258b5f90ddcd#.xhx6u325x
Plus, I can't rule out election fraud. Voter fraud, in spite of Trump's claims, is practically unheard of. Election fraud, though, I'm not so sure about. I want a paper trail and I want every ballot counted by a human being...and checked by another human being...and re-checked by another human being. This is serious business with serious consequences. We can't mess around.
In spite of all that, Clinton received nearly as many votes as Obama received in 2012 and nearly 3 million more votes than Trump received.
And and and....Clinton won among the working class. She won among individuals making $50,000 or less per year. She won among those who said 'the economy' was their top concern. If a segment of the *white* working class has much different priorities or desires than the working class as a whole, one need not think too long and hard to determine why that might be.
And anyone who thinks Trump is a "populist" is batshit crazy. Seriously, Donald Trump a populist? You've got to be kidding me. I suppose some actually believe he'll magically force corporations to bring jobs back from overseas, but he won't. Also, manufacturing in the US is at an all-time high. The problem is automation means far fewer people are needed, and wages have been stagnant for decades. What the US needs to invest in are new green industries, while raising the minimum wage and putting a cap on earnings. Plus things like paid family and medical leave, free community college, affordable college, universal health care, etc. Take a page from Germany's book. Germany also did a massive amount of outsourcing, but it's what else Germans have done that separates them from Americans.
You know, the very sorts of things Clinton campaigned on. Clinton campaigned on a very progressive economic message, the most progressive economic message ever carried by a major party candidate. And, yes, that was partly due to the influence Sanders had in the primary and on crafting the Democratic Party platform.
But Clinton's message was drowned out by the media. Issues were drowned out, period.
By the way, let me add that major proponents of free trade (including ones from the Rust Belt) won re-election by a greater margin than Trump won by. And the re-election rate of incumbents was even greater than normal. So, the anti-trade and anti-establishment narratives don't hold up to scrutiny. No, my friend, this was about bigotry first and foremost.
And the electoral college is a vestige of slavery.
As for so-called "political correctness," there's another term for it: human decency. It's not "political correctness" that objects to sexually assaulting women, to making misogynistic remarks, to suggesting most Mexican immigrants are rapists and drug dealers, to engaging in housing discrimination (as Trump has a long history of doing), etc. Those things aren't just politically incorrect. They're simply inhumane and, in some cases, illegal.
Venting over...for now. We'll see if I can stomach the rest of Bernie's misguided, self-serving lecture.
Someone sent me the video of Bernie's hour-long town hall in Wisconsin
And this was my reaction:
Okay, I'm 11 minutes in and not sure I can take much more. Bernie's dismissal of the role racism (as well as sexism) played in this election is highly irritating. And he's simply wrong when he suggests most Trump supporters aren't bigots. As Ta-Nehisi Coates points out, "Studying the 2016 election, the political scientist Philip Klinkner found that the most predictive question for understanding whether a voter favored Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump was Is Barack Obama a Muslim?'
And make no mistake, xenophobia and anti-Muslim sentiment is racism at the root. Birtherism is racism at the root.
Not to mention the 25+ years of hatred that victimized Clinton. An article on that: "The deep disgust for Hillary Clinton..."
Clinton, of course, is white, but - as Coates points out - Democrats are associated with being on the side of people who aren't white. And the white backlash has been building for the last 8 years. Survey after survey demonstrates that *many* Trump supporters subscribe to bigoted beliefs.
Then there's the FBI's interference, Russian hacking and a pathetic mainstream media (ratings-focused obsession with spectacle, and promotion of false equivalencies in the name of some twisted sense of what constitutes "balance" . An article on the media that I highly recommend: http://www.newsweek.com/neil-buchanan-cruel-crooked-caricature-doomed-clinton-520125
And, last but not least, voter suppression enabled by the Shelby County v. Holder decision of 2013. An article on its effects: https://thinkprogress.org/2016-a-case-study-in-voter-suppression-258b5f90ddcd#.xhx6u325x
Plus, I can't rule out election fraud. Voter fraud, in spite of Trump's claims, is practically unheard of. Election fraud, though, I'm not so sure about. I want a paper trail and I want every ballot counted by a human being...and checked by another human being...and re-checked by another human being. This is serious business with serious consequences. We can't mess around.
In spite of all that, Clinton received nearly as many votes as Obama received in 2012 and nearly 3 million more votes than Trump received.
And and and....Clinton won among the working class. She won among individuals making $50,000 or less per year. She won among those who said 'the economy' was their top concern. If a segment of the *white* working class has much different priorities or desires than the working class as a whole, one need not think too long and hard to determine why that might be.
And anyone who thinks Trump is a "populist" is batshit crazy. Seriously, Donald Trump a populist? You've got to be kidding me. I suppose some actually believe he'll magically force corporations to bring jobs back from overseas, but he won't. Also, manufacturing in the US is at an all-time high. The problem is automation means far fewer people are needed, and wages have been stagnant for decades. What the US needs to invest in are new green industries, while raising the minimum wage and putting a cap on earnings. Plus things like paid family and medical leave, free community college, affordable college, universal health care, etc. Take a page from Germany's book. Germany also did a massive amount of outsourcing, but it's what else Germans have done that separates them from Americans.
You know, the very sorts of things Clinton campaigned on. Clinton campaigned on a very progressive economic message, the most progressive economic message ever carried by a major party candidate. And, yes, that was partly due to the influence Sanders had in the primary and on crafting the Democratic Party platform.
But Clinton's message was drowned out by the media. Issues were drowned out, period.
By the way, let me add that major proponents of free trade (including ones from the Rust Belt) won re-election by a greater margin than Trump won by. And the re-election rate of incumbents was even greater than normal. So, the anti-trade and anti-establishment narratives don't hold up to scrutiny. No, my friend, this was about bigotry first and foremost.
And the electoral college is a vestige of slavery.
As for so-called "political correctness," there's another term for it: human decency. It's not "political correctness" that objects to sexually assaulting women, to making misogynistic remarks, to suggesting most Mexican immigrants are rapists and drug dealers, to engaging in housing discrimination (as Trump has a long history of doing), etc. Those things aren't just politically incorrect. They're simply inhumane and, in some cases, illegal.
Venting over...for now. We'll see if I can stomach the rest of Bernie's misguided, self-serving lecture.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
87 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Someone sent me the video of Bernie's hour-long town hall in Wisconsin [View all]
Garrett78
Dec 2016
OP
Well said Garrett. As to your first point, anyone who voted for Trump was well aware of his racist,
still_one
Dec 2016
#2
Please keep in mind he went to Wisconsin to talk to Trump supporters. This was outreach.
think
Dec 2016
#4
The GOP was running itself into thw grpund like this. Thank god we jumped in and adopted the tactic.
dionysus
Dec 2016
#69
Sanders will be doing a lot of this for the Democrats as outreach director. When should he start?
think
Dec 2016
#35
You nailed it! Bernie knows EXACTLY what he's doing... showing us the way out of this horrendous mess!
InAbLuEsTaTe
Dec 2016
#76
The unemployment rate has changed a lot, and changed for the better. And 20 million people have
StevieM
Dec 2016
#7
no, most of them didn't vote for obama. there are probably equal number that voted mccain and romney
JI7
Dec 2016
#18
I can't understand the people denying the racism and other hate trump spewed
montana_hazeleyes
Dec 2016
#9
thanks for pointing that out, people on these boards love to just assume shit all the time. nt
JCanete
Dec 2016
#75
I agree, but it's weird how this wasn't so noticeable in the primary about Bernie
Fast Walker 52
Dec 2016
#23
Very well said. To be honest from what (little) I saw it was one dismissal of Democrats....
George II
Dec 2016
#38
Anyone who thinks Trump won because of racism or sexism needs to step outside their bubble
NoGoodNamesLeft
Dec 2016
#41
Wow. You lived in a bigot-free rural paradise and found anti-white racism when you came to the city?
Maru Kitteh
Dec 2016
#72
The 'DEMOCRAT' Party? Curious. How many days a week do you listen to right-wing talk radio?
Maru Kitteh
Dec 2016
#49
Um...Curious, how often do you accuse people who disagree with you of being right wingers?
NoGoodNamesLeft
Dec 2016
#65
1. Nice dodge. Your assertion that only a "small percentage" of Trumpkins are bigiots is factually
Maru Kitteh
Dec 2016
#74
Garrett this is an excellent post. I too was offended when SBS picked up the RW "politicaly correct"
Maru Kitteh
Dec 2016
#47
Yes because yelling at a person that they're racist and sexist is going to make them want to listen.
PatsFan87
Dec 2016
#50
And when you call them racist or sexist, do you think they will continue listening to you?
PatsFan87
Dec 2016
#52
Numerous surveys make it clear that a majority of Trump supporters are, in fact, bigoted.
Garrett78
Dec 2016
#56
I'm not saying people should deny it. But if my job is that of the "persuader",
PatsFan87
Dec 2016
#59
Clinton won among the working class. She won among those for whom the economy is #1.
Garrett78
Dec 2016
#62
okay, but people don't vote for somebody and ALL they represent. That Trump's racism wasn't
JCanete
Dec 2016
#86
"You can be uncompromising about the truth while being polite and respectful."
Garrett78
Dec 2016
#55
Sure, but you have to choose how to engage. You have to start on a level that doesn't shut people
JCanete
Dec 2016
#78
Democrats should not waste their time and energy to people who will not vote...
asuhornets
Dec 2016
#53
You mean like yelling at Clinton supporters about our candidate being a tool
EffieBlack
Dec 2016
#82