Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Attorney in Texas

(3,373 posts)
4. I'm wondering if someone familiar with orthodox Mormon and Scientologist beliefs can tell me (or
Sat Aug 8, 2015, 01:05 PM
Aug 2015

direct me to) the official position that each group holds toward the other group (i.e., what does the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints think of Scientology and what does Scientology think of Mormonism)?

I am also wondering if other well established religions in the US have a similar (e.g., equally ecumenical or equally resistant) view of Mormonism and Scientology (e.g., does the Southern Baptist Convention take a similar view toward Mormonism and Scientology or does it take a view toward Mormonism that differs from its view toward Scientology; do the Jehovah's Witnesses take a similar view toward Mormonism and Scientology or do they take differing views toward the two groups; etc.).

If the views toward both groups are the same, I am wondering if that has always been the case or has it changed over time.

If the views are different, I'm curious about the basis for the distinction (is it a perception that one group is more Christian or monotheistic or is it based more on an evaluation that one group is more established or is it based on the percieved good works that one group has does, etc.).

For that matter, what do you -- as an atheist -- think of say the Southern Baptist Convention versus Jehovah's Witnesses versus the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints versus Scientology?

If you are an atheist (like me), are all four of those faiths equally inaccurate or is one more inaccurate than another?

Personally, I don't rank Santa Clause or the Easter Bunny or the baby delivering stork as more plausible or less plausible -- they are all myths in my view. Yet I have met atheists and Christians and Jews who totally disbelieve in certain faiths and yet seem to disbelieve more in one faith than another. For example, if you asked some friends of mine "what percentage of the believe system of the Jehovah's Witnesses do you believe?," they would say "zero percent." And of you were to ask them "what percentage of the believe system of the Scientologists do you believe?," they would say also "zero percent." But if you asked -- instead -- "what do you think of the Jehovah's Witnesses and the Scientologists?," they might express greater skepticism toward one group over the other. I'm not sure I understand that and so I am curious about it.

I couldn't rank Santa Clause or the Easter Bunny as more or less believable in my view because I 100% disbelieve in both. Likewise, I couldn't rank the beliefs of the Southern Baptist Convention versus Jehovah's Witnesses versus the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints versus Scientology as more or less believable. And yet I know other smart and rational people (both religious and atheistic) who come at this issue differently than I do, and I want to better understand why.

I understand that some people would find the questions offensive, but I mean no disrespect and I am not trying to start an argument. I am just curious.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The religion forum is the right place. Warren Stupidity Aug 2015 #1
thanks Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #2
Yeah but I wouldn't hold your breath waiting for a rational and mature discussion. mr blur Aug 2015 #18
If you want an honest discussion, I think you'd be better off posting here. deucemagnet Aug 2015 #3
I'm wondering if someone familiar with orthodox Mormon and Scientologist beliefs can tell me (or Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #4
It's an interesting question, deucemagnet Aug 2015 #5
Sorry for editing (expanding) my post simultaneous with your reply. You think there are no Mormons Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #6
I think there might be a Mormon who posts occasionally, deucemagnet Aug 2015 #8
Yeah, we think all religions suck Warpy Aug 2015 #15
Here's something vanamonde Aug 2015 #7
That's an interesting article. I've heard an atheist say Scientology is a cult but Mormonism is a Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #12
They're ALL cults, some are older and have more members.... truebrit71 Aug 2015 #14
A religion is a cult that has survived its sociopathic founder Warpy Aug 2015 #16
"reason" and "rationality" do not go over well in the religion forum. Binkie The Clown Aug 2015 #9
One person's rationality is another person's superstition (Pascal's wager is a "rational" argument Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #10
Pascal's wager makes assumptions... uriel1972 Aug 2015 #11
Pascal lived in a Catholic society so his assumptions would reflect that, but the general argument Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #13
He also neglects the fact that a life lived in the shadow of some omnipotent god Warpy Aug 2015 #17
Taken as a probabilistic wager... Binkie The Clown Aug 2015 #19
I'm not really seeking to give a dissertation defense of Pascal (a philosopher I disagree with), Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #21
I agree that not all believers are irrational. Binkie The Clown Aug 2015 #22
Truck Town restaraunt near my house. AtheistCrusader Aug 2015 #20
I had a very long thread a few years ago edhopper Aug 2015 #23
Thanks! Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #24
If you decide to read through it edhopper Aug 2015 #28
SoB's vs the Mormons onager Aug 2015 #25
Wow! I did not know that. Attorney in Texas Aug 2015 #26
I think all forms of Christianity are irrational. Manifestor_of_Light Aug 2015 #27
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»Where is the best place t...»Reply #4