Science
In reply to the discussion: A new means of space propulsion... closed loop pulse propulsion... here's the idea [View all]mikelewis
(4,184 posts)Simple questions....
In my scenario... you fire a railgun. The propulsion moves the ship opposite direction of the projectile. Since there are two railguns the propulsion is doubled. I don't think any one has any issues with this event.... simple and straightforward.
Also... with two railguns any gyroscopic effects will be cancelled out... otherwise this would induce spin. I don't think anyone has a problem with this....
Next event....
The projectile is fired into a tether and enters an arc... conserving the linear momentum and now subject to the laws of conservation of angular momentum... or is that not true? Does this scenario negate the effect of those laws and how?
The arc redirects the momentum of the projectile 180 degrees so that the projectile is released travelling in the same direction as the ship... does space make this not true?
The projectile is caught and stopped dead by a magnet and the ship then reabsorbs the force. Does space make it so forces can't combine?
To recap...
So ship is moving in direction A...
Projectile in direction B
Projectile enters an arc conserving linear motion... subject to the laws governing the conservation of angular momentum now...
The force is redirected... assuming we are allowed to redirect force in space... is it different than on Earth?
Projectile is now traveling in direction A : The projectile is now traveling in the same direction as the ship before it is untethered and strikes the ship in the same direction the Ship is travelling... A to A .. and the forces aligned in the same direction...
Questions? How does the fact that the linear motion is conserved when the projectile enters the arc allow for the linear motion to be removed from the system since is supposed to be conserved... obviously minus frictional losses
Question... how does the projectile that is traveling in the same direction as the ship subtract force when forces moving in the same direction are supposed to add together and not subtract.
You can feel free to quote me all the laws you like and call me as stupid as you want... I just would like an answer to those questions. None of them involve the laws of thermodynamics and I don't care what laws you think it's violating... or if they do, that's your problem. This is simple physics and can easily be tested using your own math or AI. That is all I want to talk about...
I am going to post this exactly into AI and attach the answer to this post... If you aren't answering these very specific questions, I honestly don't give a shit what you have to say...