Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

anobserver2

(922 posts)
33. Deception #5 in Memoir: His working life before advertising
Tue Jun 14, 2022, 10:14 AM
Jun 2022

Last edited Tue Jun 14, 2022, 04:44 PM - Edit history (2)

There are several things that do not ring true to me in Patterson's memoir about his working life prior to him going into advertising.

In his memoir he claims that during his time at Manhattan College, he and 10 friends would go to the Fillmore East and work for $12 an hour or something like that as "ushers" for music concerts.

I am finding this hard to believe on several levels.

But, I have no doubt that no matter what I may say, he can pull out 10 people (and pay them) and they will all swear on a stack of Bibles that every word in his memoir is true. So, I know: I am potentially up against a bunch of liars.

Nevertheless - here are a few things I find odd about his claim that he worked at the Fillmore East while an undergraduate:

1) His memoir never discloses his housing situation while he was at Manhattan College. I seem to recall reading his "first" apartment in NYC came after college - which means he was living in a college dormitory.

2) Manhattan College is a Roman Catholic college. I am 100% certain they would strictly enforce any policies pertaining to dorm life.

3) I am guessing: Patterson's dorm had curfews. So he (and 10 of his closest campus pals) actually could not go out at all hours of the night for their alleged work as "ushers" at a concert.

4) Here are the policies of Manhattan College posted online pertaining to dorm life:

https://inside.manhattan.edu/student-life/dean-of-students/code-conduct.php#quiethours


IV. RESIDENCE LIFE COMMUNITY STANDARDS AND CODE OF CONDUCT

A. Quiet Hours
Courtesy hours are in effect 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. This means that music, conversation, TV volumes and all other noise should be respectful of community living.

Quiet hours are from Sunday through Thursday, 11:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m. and on Friday and Saturday from midnight to 8:00 a.m. This means that music, conversation, TV volumes and all other noise should not emanate beyond one’s room.

Standard Minimum Sanctions May Result In

Reprimand. Chronic violations of quiet hours can lead to suspension from residence halls. ...



5) So, it would not surprise me if in fact: having a job such as Patterson described in his memoir would be impossible to have while living in a dorm at a college such as Manhattan College -- which I am guessing had a curfew policy that was in full force and effect while Patterson was a student there.

6) I do not have any firsthand recollection of the Fillmore East as a music venue. I read some info online. If what I read was true, then this venue (in the East Village of Manhattan) was located very far from Manhattan College (which is in the Bronx).

7) In addition, if what I read online about the Fillmore East was true, this venue, which later became the Saint nightclub, had a $5 general admission ticket price during the time it was open for concerts from 1968 to around 1971. And the multiple number of bands set to play each show were posted on the outside marquee. So - what is an usher doing? Not handing out programs or showing people to their seats, since it's general admission and there are no programs.

8) If what I read online about the Fillmore East is true, the concert promoter, Bill Graham, was known for caring about the bands and the patrons in this 2500+ seat venue, and he made certain there were medical personnel onsite at all times to help anyone who needed it.

In my own experience going to general admission concerts in venues to see musical groups, I do not ever recall dealing with any "usher."


So, for all those reasons, I do not believe Patterson's claim in his memoir that he and 10 other people worked as ushers at the Fillmore East during hie college days.

I think he lived in a dorm. I think going out at night was subject to a curfew in his dorm when he lived at this Roman Catholic college.

That is my opinion.

I also do not believe he spent summer after summer working at McLean Hospital in Belmont, MA. I think it is possible he worked there one summer, between high school and college. But I don't think he worked there every summer. It is just my gut feeling. He was not leaving his dorm in NYC in the Bronx every summer. My gut tells me he stayed in NYC during the summer in his college days.

Maybe Patterson did not have to work during his college days or college summers because: his father was now making so much money working at the Prudential Building in Boston.

Based on other info I read outside of his memoir, Patterson's parents lived in Lexington, MA, in a house. So, clearly, Patterson was not poor at this point. And I don't think he worked at any job at all during college.

Here is his mother's obituary in the local Lexington, MA newspaper online that I happened to see:

Isabelle (Morris) Patterson Obituary


Isabelle (Morris) Patterson JUPITER, Fla. Isabelle Patterson,
87, our loving mother and grandmother, passed away
Thursday, Jan. 14, 2010
. A long-term care resident of The
Pavilion @ JMC in Jupiter, she was formerly of Newburgh,
N.Y., and Lexington, Mass.
Born Jan. 17, 1922, she was the
only child of Charles and Isabelle Morris. Isabelle graduated
from the Newburgh Free Academy in 1939 and earned a
bachelor's degree from St. Joseph's College in Emmitsburg,
Md., in 1943. A devoted elementary school educator, she
taught in the parochial school system for 30 years. She was
preceded in death by her parents, Charles and Isabelle
Morris, and husband, Charles Patterson (1999). She is
survived by her son James Patterson, daughters Maryellen Patterson, Teresa Secrest and Carole Patterson, and grandchildren Brigid Dwyer, Meredith Dwyer, Andrew Klauk and Jack Patterson. With special gratitude to the staff of The Pavilion and Hospice of P.B. County, a memorial reception will be held for family, friends, staff and residents at The Pavilion, 4-6 p.m., Thursday, Feb. 4. The family requests that any memorial contributions be sent to The Pavilion @ JMC, 1230 South Old Dixie Highway, Jupiter, FL 33458. Arrangements entrusted to Aycock Funeral Home, Jupiter.

Published in The Lexington Minuteman from January 22 to January 29, 2010
Have it. Haven't gotten around to it. ReluctanceTango Jun 2022 #1
His "writing factory" gets very little space in this 300+ page memoir anobserver2 Jun 2022 #4
See pages 249-250 anobserver2 Jun 2022 #11
Thanks for the specifics ExWhoDoesntCare Apr 2023 #51
Also read this: Harvard Business Review, March 2012 anobserver2 Jun 2022 #12
And this: page 259 of his memoir (an unnumbered page) anobserver2 Jun 2022 #13
It seems he has promoted two versions of the structure of his writing factory anobserver2 Jun 2022 #14
Note to: any of his "writing factory" writers anobserver2 Jun 2022 #15
PS Here's the NY Post article about the lawsuit a writer filed against Patterson anobserver2 Jun 2022 #16
Also: Patterson's new memoir makes no mention of any lawsuit against him by a writer anobserver2 Jun 2022 #17
Two organizations for writers in the writing factory - Author's Guild and National Writers Union anobserver2 Jun 2022 #18
Questions someone should be asking these writers in his writing factory anobserver2 Jun 2022 #19
Well, of course it doesn't ExWhoDoesntCare Apr 2023 #48
I used to read all his books but now I think he just doc03 Jun 2022 #2
I think he still writes the Cross books, but other than that, I agree. rsdsharp Jun 2022 #3
Yeah, I think now he is really much more like a publisher anobserver2 Jun 2022 #5
I meant to add: And Equity, and all the other unions anobserver2 Jun 2022 #6
"crap, about crap" is the opinion of a reviewer I read - and I agree anobserver2 Jun 2022 #7
He's following the Dumas formula ExWhoDoesntCare Apr 2023 #49
James Patterson is an anomaly anobserver2 Apr 2023 #52
I do hope you meant to educate people ExWhoDoesntCare May 2023 #55
P.S. anobserver2 Apr 2023 #54
When I have time I will write a list of discrepencies I found in this memoir anobserver2 Jun 2022 #8
Excerpt from above link anobserver2 Jun 2022 #9
Well, that's a first ExWhoDoesntCare Apr 2023 #50
I think Patterson did the same thing as Frey anobserver2 Jun 2022 #10
Well, every review seems to be wonderful anobserver2 Jun 2022 #20
Great news: Library Journal panned Patterson's new memoir anobserver2 Jun 2022 #21
More about Library Journal anobserver2 Jun 2022 #22
So glad they panned it!!! anobserver2 Jun 2022 #23
The UK's Telegraph panned it, too anobserver2 Jun 2022 #24
Well, I almost thought today was Juneteenth - but it's not anobserver2 Jun 2022 #25
From June 20, 2022 New Yorker magazine: "How James Patterson Became the World's Best-Selling Author" anobserver2 Jun 2022 #26
Deception #1 in Memoir: North America anobserver2 Jun 2022 #27
Deception #2 in Memoir: Vietnam-era Law re draft anobserver2 Jun 2022 #28
Deception #3 in Memoir: Grad school / omission anobserver2 Jun 2022 #29
Deception #4 in Memoir: Re Harvard anobserver2 Jun 2022 #30
No Masters degree - he's not a "distinguished alumni" anobserver2 Jun 2022 #31
So - what was he doing from 1970-1971? anobserver2 Jun 2022 #32
Deception #5 in Memoir: His working life before advertising anobserver2 Jun 2022 #33
Deception #6 in Memoir: His false channeling of John Lennon anobserver2 Jun 2022 #34
Deception #7 in Memoir: How He Got Hired in Advertising anobserver2 Jun 2022 #35
Deception #8 in Memoir: Misrepresenting book anobserver2 Jun 2022 #36
Deception #9 in Memoir: "Outline!" anobserver2 Jun 2022 #37
Deceptions #10 #11 and #12 in Memoir to come anobserver2 Jun 2022 #38
Will try to finish this thread today anobserver2 Jun 2022 #39
Deception #10 - Pages 114-116 / Re full page ad in the NY Times 1984 anobserver2 Jun 2022 #40
Deception #11 in Memoir: Money, and Pages 120-121 - "the fine art of negociating" anobserver2 Jun 2022 #41
Deception #12 in Memoir - re Veterans anobserver2 Jun 2022 #42
Celebrity Index - Dolly Parton anobserver2 Jun 2022 #43
James Patterson & Bill O'Reilly book anobserver2 Jun 2022 #44
A Letter from James Patterson to me, August 1985 anobserver2 Feb 2023 #45
Patterson's Memoir (June 2022) vs Patterson's letter to me (August 1985) anobserver2 Feb 2023 #46
A novel idea anobserver2 Feb 2023 #47
How to Get On NYT Best Seller List anobserver2 Apr 2023 #53
RE Vietnam Draft anobserver2 Jan 2024 #56
job offer anobserver2 Jan 2024 #57
I liked these reviews on Good Reads anobserver2 Jan 2024 #58
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Non-Fiction»Has anyone read the new J...»Reply #33