Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

spin

(17,493 posts)
69. As friendly_iconoclast has pointed out the data is readily available on the internet...
Wed Feb 21, 2018, 09:45 PM
Feb 2018

Just visit https://www.bjs.gov/ or https://ucr.fbi.gov/. Lots on interesting data on those government sites.

In passing European nations may have less gun crime than the United States largely because firearms have never been as common in many of those nations compared with our nation. However that doesn’t mean they are crime free by any means.

Comparing gun violence and crime in the United States with Australia, the UK or Canada is like comparing apples and oranges. For one thing statistics are gathered differently in different nations. However I will take a shot at comparing crime between Europe and the U.S. using the articles posted below.


U.S. vs U.K. - Crime/Murder

There’s this common meme that the U.S. is so much worse than the U.K. in murders or crime, so I wanted to collect a lot of facts in one place.


A common way they mislead people is to compare gun murder rates only, instead of all murder rates. Any time you see someone comparing GUN murder rates, you know they’re a propagandist trying to deceive people.


The trends

Here’s a simple plot of the murder rates over time, for the U.S. (using the FBI’s UCR / Universal Crime Report) and U.K. (using their ONS / Office of National Statistics). And I overlay when they each enacted or removed gun controls. What you notice is:

If you look at the (the blue line): Each time the UK enacted or stiffened their gun control laws, they saw an increase in murder rates. Each new law, had no positive (and some negative) impact or an increase in murder rates. (Crime trends are even worse). (In the 1950’s they outlawed conceal and carry, in the 80’s it was shotguns, and in the late 90’s it was all pistols). So regardless of whether the UK has fewer murders than the US for cultural reasons, we know that gun control didn’t help the UK’s murder rate.

Next if you look at the (the red line): I overlaid (and adjusted) the U.S. murder rates with major gun control events. After JFK was shot, states and eventually the Fed (1968) passed all sorts of gun control laws — and what happened to our murder rates? They doubled from around 5 to 10 per 100K over the next decade, and they hovered there, despite all sorts of state and federal revisions, or more laws (30,000 different state/local/federal gun control laws were passed in total). There was no significant positive effects, and some observable negative ones in the U.S. due to our gun control laws.

Then in the late 80’s Florida passed “Must Issue” conceal and carry and castle doctrine laws were passed, and their crime/murder rates started falling noticeably. Many other states (in the South and Midwest) followed suit, with the same effects in their state murder rates, and eventually enough of those added up to start impacting the federal murder rates noticeably. Then the federal assault weapon ban expired — and if gun control worked, you’d expect an upward spike in murders, but murders trended down. Adding gun control had no positive effects, and removing them had no significant negative effects, in the U.S.!. So if you have the choice of tyranny or liberty, and there's no benefit to tyranny: opt for liberty.

Regardless of whether the UK has fewer murders than the US for cultural reasons, we know that gun control didn’t help the UK or US's murder rate. And in fact, seemed to have the opposite effect. Enacting them seemed to increase murders, and removing those allowed downward murder rates to continue.



http://igeek.com/w/U.S._vs_U.K._-_Crime/Murder



UK is violent crime capital of Europe
The United Kingdom is the violent crime capital of Europe and has one of the highest rates of violence in the world, worse even than America, according to new research.

By Richard Edwards, Crime Correspondent 7:00AM BST 02 Jul 2009

Analysis of figures from the European Commission showed a 77 per cent increase in murders, robberies, assaults and sexual offences in the UK since Labour came to power.
The total number of violent offences recorded compared to population is higher than any other country in Europe, as well as America, Canada, Australia and South Africa.

Opposition leaders said the disclosures were a "damning indictment" of the Government's failure to tackle deep-rooted social problems.

The figures combined crime statistics for England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The UK had a greater number of murders in 2007 than any other EU country – 927 – and at a relative rate higher than most western European neighbours, including France, Germany, Italy and Spain.

***snip***


The figures were sourced from Eurostat, the European Commission's database of statistics. They are gathered using official sources in the countries concerned such as the national statistics office, the national prison administration, ministries of the interior or justice, and police.

A breakdown of the statistics, which were compiled into league tables by the Conservatives, revealed that violent crime in the UK had increased from 652,974 offences in 1998 to more than 1.15 million crimes in 2007.

It means there are over 2,000 crimes recorded per 100,000 population in the UK, making it the most violent place in Europe.

Austria is second, with a rate of 1,677 per 100,000 people, followed by Sweden, Belgium, Finland and Holland.

By comparison, America has an estimated rate of 466 violent crimes per 100,000 population. (emphasis added
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/5712573/UK-is-violent-crime-capital-of-Europe.html



Police data shows crime rising at increasing rate in England and Wales
Increase of 13% in 12 months to June comes with even bigger rise in violent offences including knife crime and sexual offences

Alan Travis Home affairs editor
Thu 19 Oct 2017 09.10 EDT

The rise in crime is accelerating, with the latest figures showing a 13% increase in all police-recorded offences across England and Wales, and even greater rises for violent offences including knife crime, sexual offences and violence against the person.

The crime figures show an underlying 8% rise in the murder rate, an increase of 46 victims, with 629 homicides recorded in the 12 months to June, excluding the 35 people killed in the London and Manchester terrorist attacks, and the 96 Hillsborough deaths in 1989, which were included in the headline figures.

The acceleration from a 5% rise in the 12 months to June 2015, to 7% the following year, and 13% in the 12 months to June this year, together with even larger increases in violent crime, will sound alarm bells in Downing Street.

Theresa May might find some comfort in the results of the Crime Survey of England and Wales, which shows a 9% reduction in overall crime but is less effective at providing a good indication of changes in low-volume offences, including most forms of violent crime, or emerging trends.

John Flatley of the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said: “Today’s figures suggest that the police are dealing with a growing volume of crime. While improvements made by police forces in recording crime are still a factor in the increase, we judge that there have been genuine increases in crime, particularly in some of the low-incidence but more harmful categories.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/oct/19/rising-at-increasing-rate-in-england-and-wales-police-figures-show
Not all, but many, shootings had simple solutions. ManiacJoe Feb 2018 #1
No. Banning semi autos would have stopped Sandy Hook sharedvalues Feb 2018 #2
My M71/84 Mauser rifle was designed to kill humans, should that be banned also? Marengo Feb 2018 #3
Is it a single-shot rifle? If not, ban it. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #7
The Mauser would be legal sarisataka Feb 2018 #12
Lobbying for fewer dead Americans- killed with guns sharedvalues Feb 2018 #18
A very Noble goal sarisataka Feb 2018 #19
Interesting to think of this as a game. Permanut Feb 2018 #28
Game in the sense of sarisataka Feb 2018 #33
Well...I have my thoughts. Puha Ekapi_2 Feb 2018 #37
What about my M1884 rifle? That is a single shot military long arm designed to kill humans as well. Marengo Feb 2018 #29
Would you be so kind as to answer my questions in post #29? Marengo Feb 2018 #34
Do not expect an answer. The have only generalities and insults. n/t oneshooter Feb 2018 #35
"large numbers of unregulated guns" AzureCrest Feb 2018 #4
Regulate like Canada. Where there are fewer gun deaths. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #8
Still not "unregulated ". AzureCrest Feb 2018 #11
Children are killed because of weakly regulated guns sharedvalues Feb 2018 #16
"Thin-slicing language" AzureCrest Feb 2018 #24
To follow the logic of this argument, we would ban sober drivers. Hangingon Feb 2018 #39
Exactly. AzureCrest Feb 2018 #40
Poor timing with your pro-gun comments, sir. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #41
Suggesting that guns are the sole problem... discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #26
Australia and Canada put the lie to NRA stats. Fewer guns, fewer deaths. See the chart. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #42
What NRA stats? I see no NRA stats in your pic. discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #43
Reality: Australia, Canada: strict gun laws. Few DEATHS. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #44
re:"Let's be clear: if you support more guns in the US, you're complicit in American kids' deaths." discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #45
If you are anti-gun control, you are complicit sharedvalues Feb 2018 #46
Canada bans sarisataka Feb 2018 #13
Canada: hard to carry. Strictly regulated sharedvalues Feb 2018 #15
There is no doubt that gun sales have skyrocketed in recent decades. spin Feb 2018 #21
Those stats are flawed. You expect linear correlation? sharedvalues Feb 2018 #47
If more firearms equals more crime than why has the crime rate decreased? spin Feb 2018 #61
Before you use stats, go take a stats class sharedvalues Feb 2018 #62
Ill just stick with FBI and Bureau of Justice Statistics. ... spin Feb 2018 #63
Sorry: NRA banned gov't stats. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #66
Bullshit: The FBI's crime statistics are available online to all: https://ucr.fbi.gov/ friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #67
In the UK's case, gejohnston Feb 2018 #68
As friendly_iconoclast has pointed out the data is readily available on the internet... spin Feb 2018 #69
Google is your friend discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #70
Please read. How many times do I have to show you all the quote? Please read. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #71
Prevented from collecting stats yagotme Feb 2018 #72
You're backpedaling-your claim changed when the FBI's freely available stats were pointed out. friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #73
like Canada........ gejohnston Feb 2018 #25
Handguns are basically banned in Canada sharedvalues Feb 2018 #48
IOW, guns embolden deaths. Thank you for Loudly giving your opinion friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #49
not sure sharedvalues Feb 2018 #50
De nada. As an aside, I've always had a fondness for zombies... friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #54
no they are not, gejohnston Feb 2018 #58
+1 discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #59
Read above: Handguns effectively banned in Canada. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #78
Pol Pot? gejohnston Feb 2018 #83
"...equating Pol Pot with the kids that died at Sandy Hook?" No, pointing out blatant demagoguery friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #84
Doubling down on wrong. Straw Man Feb 2018 #74
This has been the world's longest running 'Gish gallop': friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #75
I agree. We need to ban handguns, and gun-fetishists have been Gish galloping. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #77
I don't doubt that you believe every word you write when you write it n/t friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #82
Thanks. My kids are at risk from guns. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #85
I don't believe you understand the actual meaning of what I said friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #86
I want to stop kid gun killings. And Im an optimist. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #87
We all do. The debate of the moment is how best to do that friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #88
"Getting an AR-15-style rifle is much harder in Canada than the U.S." - Largest TV network in Canada sharedvalues Feb 2018 #76
So ... Straw Man Feb 2018 #79
It seems spreading bullshit for too long causes one to start to believe what they're handing out... friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #81
It's cute that your standard seems to be: "Someone else said so too, so that *proves* I'm right!" friendly_iconoclast Feb 2018 #80
Wow.... AncientGeezer Feb 2018 #6
Whatabout pools? Guns kill Americans, dont change the subject sharedvalues Feb 2018 #9
I read the article..it says guns are the THIRD cause of those between AncientGeezer Feb 2018 #14
Are you pro-gun control? sharedvalues Feb 2018 #17
Not your version of gun control....I MOST certainly do know about American AncientGeezer Feb 2018 #20
When would that ban have to have been put in place? Hangingon Feb 2018 #38
In the common sense of the word "child"... discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #5
Girl in picture, Olivia, was torn apart by semiauto rifle sharedvalues Feb 2018 #10
Good luck with that. AzureCrest Feb 2018 #22
You haven't really thought this out have you...? AncientGeezer Feb 2018 #23
He still hasn't answered how he plans to pay oneshooter Feb 2018 #27
More than likely he won't... discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2018 #31
The children of Latarsha Sanders were torn apart with a kitchen knife wielded by her. The oldest... Marengo Feb 2018 #30
If it isn't done with a knife, axe or other sharp pointy oneshooter Feb 2018 #32
How to reduce knife violence: yagotme Feb 2018 #36
The subject is gun violence. You're engaging in whataboutism. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #53
Ah, I understand. Her death is more important as it serves your agenda. Marengo Feb 2018 #55
Dead toddlers are more important than people shooting for fun. Yes. sharedvalues Feb 2018 #56
Latarsha Sanders didnt kill her children with a gun. So, lets hear some of you ideas on how... Marengo Feb 2018 #57
Stopping parents from murdering their kids because of religious delusions and... moriah Feb 2018 #60
Latarsha Sanders shouldnt have had access to a lethal weapons. Background checks for the... Marengo Feb 2018 #64
Andrea Yates shouldn't have been left alone with water, either. moriah Feb 2018 #65
Her death is important, period. flibbitygiblets Feb 2018 #89
If your agenda is no more dead kids than I imagine you given some thought on the deaths Marengo Feb 2018 #90
Godspeed sweet Angel Olivia.... samnsara Feb 2018 #51
it is so sad sharedvalues Feb 2018 #52
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»Children Are Dying Becaus...»Reply #69