Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

tortoise1956

(671 posts)
33. You have no idea how much this pains me..
Tue Oct 3, 2017, 03:27 PM
Oct 2017

But I have to agree with at least part of Jimmy's post. (Yeah, I know, someone just turned on the AC in Hades...)

While I firmly believe in the second amendment, bearing arms does not necessarily mean that you should be able to go out in public with a pistol strapped on your side and an AR-15 slung over one shoulder with no restrictions at all. NO right is completely unlimited - hell, even Scalia noted that in Heller.

So:

As long as there is a Shall-Issue statute that allows law-abiding people to obtain a CCW license (without having to jump through unreasonable hoops to qualify), I am fine with banning open carry of a weapon in municipalities and other government-controlled areas. This,. of course, does not mean that you can't take a weapon to a range or back and forth between private residences.

OK, flame away.

Ban the Open Carry of Firearms [View all] SecularMotion Aug 2017 OP
But what about Antonin Scalia and his "discovery" of what he called "original intent"? guillaumeb Aug 2017 #1
Scalia said you can ban open carry hack89 Aug 2017 #8
Ban them all. bullimiami Aug 2017 #2
We've Been Told sarisataka Aug 2017 #4
More blowback from your side's culture war krispos42 Aug 2017 #3
"Gun Control" is the most effective form of firearm proliferation known to this country. n/t Decoy of Fenris Aug 2017 #5
Agreed discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2017 #6
historical diffs between open & concealed carry jimmy the one Aug 2017 #7
I'm not being snarky Lokilooney Aug 2017 #9
heartbroken jimmy the one Aug 2017 #10
Translation Lokilooney Aug 2017 #12
You have no idea how much this pains me.. tortoise1956 Oct 2017 #33
Technically OC should discourage harassment and intimidation. ileus Aug 2017 #11
It wasn't just white supremacists and nazis who were armed at Charlottesville. EL34x4 Aug 2017 #13
Sounds like something Trump would say SecularMotion Aug 2017 #14
And if he said it, he would be correct. EL34x4 Aug 2017 #15
Civil Liberties Body ACLU Will No Longer Defend Gun-Carrying Protest Groups SecularMotion Aug 2017 #16
Do you support denying a Constitutional right based on being on a government list? The ACLU doesn't: friendly_iconoclast Aug 2017 #18
Their argument against using the no-fly watchlist is that the system is broken. SecularMotion Aug 2017 #20
What about states already using those lists to deny gun permits? New Jersey does: friendly_iconoclast Aug 2017 #21
I agree with the position of the ACLU SecularMotion Aug 2017 #22
I agree with it as well- also, that article is as clear as mud friendly_iconoclast Aug 2017 #23
If the ACLU had defended the 2nd amendment, the NRA would not be the political power it now is. Hangingon Aug 2017 #28
Sometimes folks that oppose carrying... discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2017 #17
These folks don't oppose carrying. They're proudly pro-gun and progressive. EL34x4 Aug 2017 #25
Rednecks! Obviously liberals! pablo_marmol Aug 2017 #19
I'll see your Blair Mountain and raise you a... discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2017 #24
! pablo_marmol Aug 2017 #27
To all my "retrumplican before country" brethren Tortue Aug 2017 #26
if you're addressing "retrumplican before country" brethren... discntnt_irny_srcsm Aug 2017 #29
I would stay away from any event where people were going to open carry Kaleva Sep 2017 #30
I have no problem with open carry. ManiacJoe Sep 2017 #31
I agree AR-15s on chest rigs are a bit more than open carry. mackdaddy Oct 2017 #32
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»Ban the Open Carry of Fir...»Reply #33