Creative Speculation
In reply to the discussion: 9/11 Debunked: "Molten Metal" Explained [View all]AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)You cannot, because it has never been assayed.
You do know what an ASSAY is, right, mr. 'I work with steel'?
There is no assay. Period. He hasn't had one performed. Try again.
You create false analogies.
"Your demand for photos is like that of a desperate defense attorney telling the jury: "The prosecution's does not have any photos to back up his claim that my client shot the decedent.""
Error. Correct analogy: You have not shown that the decedent was shot at all.
You have, at best, produced a couple witnesses that claim to have heard a gunshot.
You have not produced a decedent/autopsy with injuries consistent with a gunshot.
"It is unreasonable to think that a PhD science writer for the NYT would jeopardize his credibility by claiming he saw melted steel without making some effort to satisfy himself that it was in fact melted steel. If you think he was lying, go ahead prove it."
No it isn't. People make mistakes. I don't need to prove anything, he never specified and still has not specified how or why he though the material he allegedly observed was steel. Any methods to verify were completely made up by you.
"The sources of melted steel are 250,000 tons of steel. A couple of dozen witnesses have spoken about it. 8 of them are PhDs. Your desperation is showing."
And that is all you have. A few witnesses, and not one of which actually talks about ESTABLISHING what metal they observed. Not one. No samples. No photos. Astaneh's photos do not show molten steel, or steel that was melted as in slag.
It's a little easier than you think to get sulfite out of drywall, I think. Recall all the shit from China that was recalled in 2005-2008 because it was eating peoples plumbing and making people sick. That's why I specified multiple sources of drywall over decades of building life, for each remodel of interior surfaces. In the presence of carbon monoxide, it'll release it at as low as 600c. Basic chemistry. Plenty of carbon monoxide in the rubble, from burning material from the ~80 acres of office stuff per tower that wasn't burned in the initial impact and fire.