Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sabbat hunter

(6,894 posts)
14. If the Arab Armies
Fri Feb 16, 2018, 12:34 PM
Feb 2018

Last edited Fri Feb 16, 2018, 05:43 PM - Edit history (1)

had defeated Israel in the War of Independence, there likely still would not have been a Palestine formed. It probably would have been split up between Egypt, Jordan, Syria, with a likely war between those three to see who controlled what areas.

Even before the declaration of the state of Israel, Jordan tried to come to an agreement with Ben-Gurion and Golda Meir, to not declare independence, and instead become a part of Jordan/TransJordan, with guaranteed seats in their parliament, etc. There would have been no state of Palestine.
It really wasn't until after 67 when Israel captured the WB that the Arab countries suddenly found a passion for a state of Palestine. Otherwise they could have declared one well before that.

This is not to say that Palestinians do not deserve their own state (based in most of the WB with the exception of the old city of Jerusalem). They can have their capital in the eastern sections of Jerusalem, outside of the old city.

edited to correct eastern where I had western.


It seems to me Israel loses the high ground here if they imprison an unarmed girl for slapping an Nitram Feb 2018 #1
Like Shitler, anything that can be ignited for use as a racial flame will be doused with gas. Fred Sanders Feb 2018 #2
seriously? Mosby Feb 2018 #3
Isn't the soldier part of an occupying army that has invaded this girl's homeland? Nitram Feb 2018 #4
So hypothetically aranthus Feb 2018 #5
Interesting analogy. Nitram Feb 2018 #6
The Palestinians started the war. aranthus Feb 2018 #7
The Palestinians have not committee the atrocities that the Germany did. But Israel Nitram Feb 2018 #8
It's not about atrocities. aranthus Feb 2018 #9
You narrow the topic to suit your beliefs. I stand by my previous post. Nitram Feb 2018 #10
No. You are bringing in irrelevant assertions. aranthus Feb 2018 #11
The occupation of Germany was by inernational agreement to keep the peace after a World War Nitram Feb 2018 #12
International agreements? aranthus Feb 2018 #20
If the Arab Armies sabbat hunter Feb 2018 #14
"They can have their capital in the western sections of Jerusalem, outside of the old city." Nitram Feb 2018 #15
If you notice sabbat hunter Feb 2018 #17
I see your point. I agree. Nitram Feb 2018 #18
I think it's much worse than that. aranthus Feb 2018 #19
I think that sabbat hunter Feb 2018 #21
Maybe, but it's hard to explain two things. aranthus Feb 2018 #22
I agree sabbat hunter Feb 2018 #23
First off sabbat hunter Feb 2018 #13
Sabbat, you are a little confused. Aranthis was comparing Palestinians to Germans, not Israelis. Nitram Feb 2018 #16
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»Ahed Tamimi: Palestinian ...»Reply #14