Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

shira

(30,109 posts)
12. Gush Shalom is pushing for it. Apparently Arafat agreed...
Wed Sep 14, 2016, 10:00 AM
Sep 2016
.would these future Jewish settlers be willing to live under Palestinian rule ???
Without the back up of the IDF ????
I seriously doubt it .


I think they'd be crazy to do it but they should have that choice.
The PA should guarantee their safety, just as they would any other citizens of Palestine.

They can choose to ....If you truly believe in a two state solution ....they can choose to leave or to stay .....if they choose to stay .....then should it be based on their believe of reconciliation ( which IMHO is nothing but a pile of horseshit )...........
or their believe that God promised them Judea and Samaria ?????????


Who cares why they'd stay? Their choice, their ancestral & cultural indigenous homeland. They don't have to be religious at all to believe that's their historical homeland. That's just a fact of history.

We are heading towards a civil war shira ......


Doubt it.
Forced population transfer of Jews is ethnic cleansing by every definition. shira Sep 2016 #1
Correction aranthus Sep 2016 #2
80 years ago, they all screamed at Jews to go to Palestine.... shira Sep 2016 #3
K+R. Israeli Sep 2016 #4
Your Gush Shalom! Far-left group: Palestinian citizenship for Jews shira Sep 2016 #5
Yes I am shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #6
Gush Shalom in agreement with Netanyahu. How about that? n/t shira Sep 2016 #8
Us ......" in agreement with Netanyahu. " ......... Israeli Sep 2016 #9
Yep. A future Palestine absorbing Jewish settlers as Palestinian citizens. n/t shira Sep 2016 #10
Sounds great shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #11
Gush Shalom is pushing for it. Apparently Arafat agreed... shira Sep 2016 #12
You doubt it all you like shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #13
Palestinian intolerance. From the end of that article... shira Sep 2016 #14
shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #15
In no other situation of occupation/settlements worldwide is there a demand... shira Sep 2016 #16
It bothers me shira ..... Israeli Sep 2016 #17
I can't tell it bothers you. Mention Rabin to any obsessed critic of Israel.... shira Sep 2016 #20
Feh back at you . Israeli Sep 2016 #21
Still doesn't explain why post-Zios embrace anti-Zionists who hate Rabin... shira Sep 2016 #24
Not this post zionist shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #25
What's up with yet another OP from a vile racist like Gideon Levy? shira Sep 2016 #7
So Let the Settlers Stay. They Won't. Israeli Sep 2016 #18
Silly article. Why won't the settlers stay? Why? He doesn't answer. shira Sep 2016 #19
Gershom Gorenberg is a "fraud"...... Israeli Sep 2016 #22
Well yeah. But let's see if you can do better. Why, why, why..... shira Sep 2016 #23
Ok ......easy answer ... Israeli Sep 2016 #26
Of course it's easy & I agree. Which goes to show.... shira Sep 2016 #27
shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #28
So the Gaza pullout was so successful, it should be repeated in the W.Bank? shira Sep 2016 #29
Your ideology versus mine .... Israeli Sep 2016 #30
So if you're peace, what do you propose? shira Sep 2016 #31
The settlers that want to stay .... Israeli Sep 2016 #32
Okay, that's fine but what about peace? You want no occupation w/o a peace agreement..... shira Sep 2016 #33
You dont shira .... Israeli Sep 2016 #34
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»Yes, Netanyahu, Let's Tal...»Reply #12