Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Education
In reply to the discussion: Former NYC School Chancellor Joel Klein Is Not Telling the Whole Truth About His Personal History [View all]George II
(67,782 posts)44. Final word on this since I'm butting up against a brick wall........
...he NEVER described where he lived as a "tenement"
...the objective of "public housing" when it was created in the early 1930s was what you say, but by the early 1950s (about 20 years later) that objective had changed dramatically, not how you portray it.
...he NEVER said his parents couldn't read - I KNEW you would cite that quote - and figured it would be out of context. He said in that sentence
"Nobody in school said to me, Well, you grew up in public housing, your parents dont read"
How could you POSSIBLY conclude, after he stated that his father dropped out of high school in the 10th grade and his mother graduated from high school, that he "impugned the memory of his dead parents" - surely you're knowledeable enough to know that no one gets through the 10th grade or graduates from high school without being able to read.
Obviously you have an agenda, and you'll twist words to forward that agenda. And you misrepresent his statement to that aim - he said "NOBODY...said...your parents don't read"!!!!!!
Sheesh..............it's unbelievable.
Take care!
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
50 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Former NYC School Chancellor Joel Klein Is Not Telling the Whole Truth About His Personal History [View all]
xchrom
Oct 2012
OP
Public housing 60 years ago was built for returning war veterans and their family..
no_hypocrisy
Oct 2012
#1
"Public housing projects" were created in 1933 during the Roosevelt Administration....
George II
Oct 2012
#6
The point of the post is clearly that not all public housing was "the projects"
starroute
Oct 2012
#7
Public housing in NYC (I grew up in Brooklyn too - was born only 2 years after he was)....
George II
Oct 2012
#8
not only does he lie by implying woodside houses = 'the projects,' he impugns his parents' memory
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#41
People don't "lie" by "implying" - it's in the hands and minds of the listener or reader.......
George II
Oct 2012
#42
Why? Because what is being said about him in the sweeping proclamations about him is.......
George II
Oct 2012
#46
weren't you going away? wasn't that your last post? take it up with the writer, who grew up
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#47
All you say about those disqualifying factors and and "filters" had been abandoned by 1955......
George II
Oct 2012
#48
take it up with the writer. you're the one with no material facts. you've posted nothing but
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#49
I read the words the way they were written, not how I want them to be written, as you've done.
George II
Oct 2012
#50
the fact is that the public housing project klein lived in was neither a low-income 'project' nor
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#19
And what is the most important component of those excellent schools? GOOD teachers.
George II
Oct 2012
#14
impossible to keep politics out of *any* kind of education -- private, public, religious, etc. all
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#29
i'm not clear on what you mean by politics, as in 'how to,' testing, etc. could you give an
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#25
if you could give me an example of what you mean. there's always been an intersection of
HiPointDem
Oct 2012
#28