Men's Group
In reply to the discussion: Poll: Would anyone here object to or be offended by skimpy outfits on male volleyball team members? [View all]TheKentuckian
(25,939 posts)Would you seek out non-medical advice from a person just because they were a neurosurgeon?
Would you trust a person with your life in a non-medically related scenario just because they were a neurosurgeon?
How about a mechanic, or sculptor, or an architect, or a salesman, or nurse, or a chef, or about anything? I bet those folks might get some worth out of what they do.
I don't see the test as reasonable. President seems like a fair fit to the questions but to be honest, the job it's self considering many, if not most of the occupants, doesn't seem to qualify either. I bet with easy access to one of the Bushes many here would just call a friend or a family member that does hair or is a cube rat, or cuts grass, or what the hell ever and feel much stronger about the choice.
The answer is there isn't a job in the world the solely qualifies anyone to meet the criteria. They might result in situationally meeting one or more like if trusting your life to the heart surgeon who might not be as trustworthy with fixing your brakes. Or you might feel comfort and benefit talking to Peggy about your taxes because she is also an accountant but her advice on the affects of infertility on a couple maybe less than useful.
You may or may not be on target but I believe your test is poor.