Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

patphil

(8,666 posts)
10. It has one benefit. The kids will be able to see how many commandments the adults regularly break.
Mon Jan 20, 2025, 06:02 PM
Jan 2025

Of course these commandments are not all that clear; their open to interpretation...a lot of interpretation.
For instance, is it OK to bear false witness against someone who isn't your neighbor?
And how about lying; that doesn't seem to be covered except the bear false witness part.
Or, can you covet your neighbor's husband?
Adultery is bad, but sex outside of marriage isn't covered, so is it OK?
Thou shall not kill, but is it OK to wound?
Thou shall not steal, but is "long term" borrowing OK?
And how do you know you're taking God's name in vain? Maybe you aren't.
And is it not holy to drink beer and shout obscenities at the referee while watching Sunday football?

Think about it, most people break 2 or 3 commandments each day; some even more.
I think it's because there are too many loopholes in the lists; too many generalizations.
What's a person to do?
I think it's unrealistic to put all this stuff on our children, when it means so little to the adults.
My feeling is that the list as compiled by Moses is pretty worthless as anything other than a guideline.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What happened to religious freedom of the !st Amendment? Everyone isn't a Christian. brush Jan 2025 #1
Our legal system owes more to the pagan Anglo-Saxons than to the Hebrew Bible DBoon Jan 2025 #2
Why not hang a copy of Charlton Heston's walk of fame star along with them? RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Jan 2025 #3
The Ten Commandments is Trump's "to do" list. surfered Jan 2025 #4
I want religion taught in schools - as long as it's my religion. nature-lover Jan 2025 #5
If they force children to follow that, then there should be far less republicans when they turn 18. C Moon Jan 2025 #6
The Republic of Gilead Miguelito Loveless Jan 2025 #7
One step closer to living in caves again. twodogsbarking Jan 2025 #8
The peculiar thing is the 10Cs came from Moses Bluetus Jan 2025 #9
Many ancient history scholars believe it originated from the Egyptian "Negative Confessions" BumRushDaShow Jan 2025 #11
Some of these values are commun to hundreds or thousands Bluetus Jan 2025 #14
The irony is that the old testament that christians claim to believe in JoseBalow Jan 2025 #15
Beyond that, Mark 15:3 (of the New Testament) Bluetus Jan 2025 #17
He was considered a heretic BumRushDaShow Jan 2025 #24
Yes they are "moral codes" BumRushDaShow Jan 2025 #16
Jewish people know they don't have the numbers to do that. Old Crank Jan 2025 #23
It has one benefit. The kids will be able to see how many commandments the adults regularly break. patphil Jan 2025 #10
Put up more statues of Baphomet in protest sakabatou Jan 2025 #12
Ten Commandments are just empty words to republicans. keithbvadu2 Jan 2025 #13
History is at stake? lonely bird Jan 2025 #18
I just dont get what Figarosmom Jan 2025 #19
I agree, all they want is "liberal tears". Let's not give it to them Walleye Jan 2025 #26
May they be sued by every non-Christian group. Beacool Jan 2025 #20
... Be doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves; for a man who hears without doing struggle4progress Jan 2025 #21
Establishing religious dominance Old Crank Jan 2025 #22
I was in a religious school grades 1-2. The 10 commandments were posted. travelingthrulife Jan 2025 #25
Maybe it'll give the school shooters a good target to shoot at with their A.R. 15s Walleye Jan 2025 #27
"Fuck your free will, Americans." - G.O.P. Idolators, Inc. BoRaGard Jan 2025 #28
Yet they worship BigMin28 Jan 2025 #29
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Texas could join Louisian...»Reply #10