Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: The 20 Most Historically Inaccurate Movies Ever [View all]MinM
(2,650 posts)112. Aside from portraying J Edgar as a defender of Civil Rights...
it was pretty good.
A Perversion of the Past (MISSISSIPPI BURNING)
For most of its history, including the 60s, the FBI has been a racist organization. This isnt simply a matter of hearsay or folk wisdom; its amply demonstrated in such places as I.F. Stones 1961 article, The Negro, the FBI and Police Brutality, James Farmers Lay Bare the Heart, and any Martin Luther King biography you care to pick. (The protracted persecution of King by J. Edgar Hoover is now part of the public record.) Its even come to light recently, when a black FBI agent brought charges of racial harassment against his colleagues. In 1964, of course, there was no such thing as a black FBI agent anywhere in the U.S.
Unfortunately, the central narrative premise of Mississippi Burning sets up the FBI as the sole heroic defender of the victims of southern racism in 1964, which is more than a little disgusting. Embracing the premise unconditionally unless one counts a single fleeting remark from a redneck, to a journalist, that J. Edgar Hoover said Martin Luther King was a Communist, which the film neither confirms nor privileges the film tampers more than a little with historical facts: it subverts the history of the civil rights movement itself...
http://www.jonathanrosenbaum.com/?p=7601
For most of its history, including the 60s, the FBI has been a racist organization. This isnt simply a matter of hearsay or folk wisdom; its amply demonstrated in such places as I.F. Stones 1961 article, The Negro, the FBI and Police Brutality, James Farmers Lay Bare the Heart, and any Martin Luther King biography you care to pick. (The protracted persecution of King by J. Edgar Hoover is now part of the public record.) Its even come to light recently, when a black FBI agent brought charges of racial harassment against his colleagues. In 1964, of course, there was no such thing as a black FBI agent anywhere in the U.S.
Unfortunately, the central narrative premise of Mississippi Burning sets up the FBI as the sole heroic defender of the victims of southern racism in 1964, which is more than a little disgusting. Embracing the premise unconditionally unless one counts a single fleeting remark from a redneck, to a journalist, that J. Edgar Hoover said Martin Luther King was a Communist, which the film neither confirms nor privileges the film tampers more than a little with historical facts: it subverts the history of the civil rights movement itself...
http://www.jonathanrosenbaum.com/?p=7601
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
188 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
I totally believed it until I saw the guy riding the motorcycle across the lunar surface.
Warren DeMontague
Jun 2013
#27
I'm going to take it that your "." and mocking smilie mean you disagree with the
MADem
Jun 2013
#143
So you don't want your POV to be granted any credence, then. Thanks for clearing that up. nt
MADem
Jun 2013
#147
Could virtually all modern scholars of antiquity agree that Mithra existed?
AnotherMcIntosh
Jun 2013
#59
I found the website for your source on the internet, for those who are interested.
MADem
Jun 2013
#146
If you won't acknowledge that an overwhelming majority of secular historians
Nye Bevan
Jun 2013
#116
How do we know anyone we never met existed? Did Pontius Pilot really exist do you think?
sabrina 1
Jun 2013
#137
There is actual contemporary Roman evidence for the existence of Pontius Pilate
DavidDvorkin
Jun 2013
#140
How do we know anyone existed? Well, usually there is corroborating evidence from several sources...
Moonwalk
Jun 2013
#181
Don't get me started. Flares are no better than a microphone dropping from the top of the screen
arcane1
Jun 2013
#133
But it is NOT disregarded! In fact, if you recall the "Mirror, Mirror" universe, it is regarded--
Moonwalk
Jun 2013
#180
The Doors jumps out at me. That was depressing. Every day couldn't have been a bad day. You knew
brewens
Jun 2013
#8
I watched Stone's company commander on C-Span2, plugging his book. I can't remember the
brewens
Jun 2013
#173
I can't get over the fact that when Jim stalks and peeps on his soon to be girlfriend
Springslips
Jun 2013
#163
Also the "liberal journalist" sees the error of his ways and embraces the war effort without...
Tom Ripley
Jun 2013
#24
I spent a year in Nha Trang, and I can testify that the sun NEVER set over the South China Sea
Glorfindel
Jun 2013
#106
Huh? You mean I'm not Spartacus? Does that mean that I have to let all of the Helots I
patrice
Jun 2013
#76
I watched that and "The Patriot" in the same week; I still have scars. (nt)
Posteritatis
Jun 2013
#21
That is because the name Affleck and the word watchable can not be used in the same sentence.
1-Old-Man
Jun 2013
#23
I totally agree that it's unfair to include Amadeus on this list. It never claimed to be historical.
scarletwoman
Jun 2013
#120
Unfortunately it seems that many people do learn their history from movies...
uriel1972
Jun 2013
#87
"Ms de Carlo then takes up with the reformed bandit" Well at least she ended up with Herman Munster.
L0oniX
Jun 2013
#46
JFK is about Garrison, not about JFK. The film portrays Garrison very accurately.
Bluenorthwest
Jun 2013
#153
I'm surprised "We Were Soldiers" wasn't on the list. They outright made an American victory up.
Dash87
Jun 2013
#70
If you want the facts go to the library and read a book .. otherwise it's just entertainment...>>
YOHABLO
Jun 2013
#79
What spoiled it for me, was the Samurai had been training all their lives
MichaelMcGuire
Jun 2013
#95
What is really becoming noticeable is any movie whose plot revolves around not..
Tikki
Jun 2013
#111
In "The Fugitive" the police take something like 15 seconds to trace a call.
GreenStormCloud
Jun 2013
#119
"Fellowship of the Ring" should have gotten adapted screenplay Oscar over "A Beautiful Mind"...
cascadiance
Jun 2013
#165
I wonder which of the many films about the Earps and the Clantons is considered the most accurate?
Gidney N Cloyd
Jun 2013
#168