General Discussion

Melon

(972 posts)

19. They've discussed killing the penny forever.

Reply to jmowreader (Original post)

Sat Dec 13, 2025, 10:54 PM

Saturday

It’s outlived its life. The penny isn’t worth enough anymore to manufacture.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

rollin74

49 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Trump's claimed justification for ending the penny makes no sense at all [View all] jmowreader Saturday OP

How did he make money killing the penny? Irish_Dem Saturday #1

I stumbled upon a right wing screed recently which for some reason... Hugin Saturday #13

Who gets all the pennies, and how much are they worth? Irish_Dem Yesterday #37

Personally, I believe it goes back to a grudge against a dead guy. Hugin 23 hrs ago #38

Getting revenge and grifting at the same time. Irish_Dem 23 hrs ago #39

Americans are weakest about what... Hugin 23 hrs ago #40

The evil geniuses installed the perfect snake oil salesman. Irish_Dem 21 hrs ago #42

Except They're Not Rare Earth Metals ProfessorGAC 15 hrs ago #49

lincoln freed theslaves very bad person rampartd Saturday #26

Oh geez I had not thought of that. Of course. Irish_Dem 21 hrs ago #43

That's a good argument. Should be shared widely. bucolic_frolic Saturday #2

I haven't heard one issue he's tackling make any sense or justification for his decisions..the penny Deuxcents Saturday #3

This is not a new idea, as far back as 2008 Abolishinist Saturday #4

next time you run for president promise to implode the ball room rampartd Saturday #30

Pennies were eliminated in Canada a long time ago. jeffreyi Saturday #5

Other countries think this through and do planned phase-outs rather than just act on impulse. Eugene Saturday #8

During WWII, pennies were made out of steel Deminpenn Saturday #23

There's a whole documentary about it. eggplant Saturday #16

Its inevitable. Not Trumps idea. Just common sense. LiberalLovinLug Saturday #18

On top of that, if cost relative to value was the real issue, nickels should be discontinued first. Wiz Imp Saturday #6

The volume of nickels shouldn't need to increase if the penny is discontinued. eggplant Saturday #17

Most experts disagree with you including the Federal Reserve. Wiz Imp Saturday #28

Locally, Giant Eagle grocery stores offered $1 in gift cards for every 50 penny roll Deminpenn Saturday #27

A mill is one tenth of a penny Bmoboy Saturday #7

Krugman says the penny is no longer relevant. It is obsolete. We should also start minting one-dollar and two-dollar Martin68 Saturday #9

The problem with that is vending machines don't take dollar coins Deminpenn Saturday #29

In Canada our vending machines take $1 and $2 coins. Most adults use their debit or credit cards on the machines. Bev54 Saturday #32

That's nice to know Deminpenn Saturday #34

Exactly. I used to spend every summer in Ontario, and I thought one and two dollar coins were great. Martin68 16 hrs ago #47

Yes most people have their cards on their phones now so just tap the phone. Bev54 15 hrs ago #48

If the penny is dead, BlueSpot Yesterday #35

That's like a blacksmith saying "we don't have horseshoes for automobiles. Let's stick with horses." Martin68 16 hrs ago #46

It is an issue when you're dealing with a moron that can only focus on one thought at a time. Trump is really flashman13 Saturday #10

Translation: Bessent plans on embezzling the nation's copper reserves. intheflow Saturday #11

Not really a lot of copper in pennies any more... Wounded Bear Saturday #21

Even so, a quart jar full of pennies is $18.00 yellowdogintexas Yesterday #36

Actually, I don't think pennies circulate much at all. patphil Saturday #12

much hue and cry in advocacy - for a token that consumers in large part refuse to use stopdiggin Saturday #15

He wants to destroy everything and anything he can. RockRaven Saturday #14

They've discussed killing the penny forever. Melon Saturday #19

Yeah, they can blame/give credit to trump if they like, but it's been in the works for a while...nt Wounded Bear Saturday #22

That's right, it doesn't make any cents! KelleyKramer Saturday #20

If a penny costs 3.69 cents to make, but a dollar only costs 4.1 cents to make*, then the face value argument... Ol Janx Spirit Saturday #24

Even if so, the thing to do is to make 2-cent coins that look almost like cents (not pennies -- there is no US penny). eppur_se_muova Saturday #25

Getting rid of the penny is a fairly old idea dsc Saturday #31

Seigniorage Deminpenn Saturday #33

1/2 Cent, Two-Cent piece, Three Cent piece, Silver Half-Dimes, Twenty-Cent piece, and Emile 23 hrs ago #41

I hate having loose coins. MichMan 21 hrs ago #44

In Panama, pennies are necessary PJMcK 20 hrs ago #45