Nothing Left: The long, slow surrender of American liberals

[eridani]

http://harpers.org/archive/2014/03/nothing-left-2/?single=1#sthash.rGTdOzxY.dpuf

But if the left is tied to a Democratic strategy that, at least since the Clinton Administration, tries to win elections by absorbing much of the right’s social vision and agenda, before long the notion of a political left will have no meaning. For all intents and purposes, that is what has occurred. If the right sets the terms of debate for the Democrats, and the Democrats set the terms odebate for the left, then what can it mean to be on the political left? The terms “left” and “progressive” — and in practical usage the latter is only a milquetoast version of the former — now signify a cultural sensibility rather than a reasoned critique of the existing social order. Because only the right proceeds from a clear, practical utopian vision, “left” has come to mean little more than “not right.”

The left has no particular place it wants to go. And, to rehash an old quip, if you have no destination, any direction can seem as good as any other. The left careens from this oppressed group or crisis moment to that one, from one magical or morally pristine constituency or source of political agency (youth/students; undocumented immigrants; the Iraqi labor movement; the Zapatistas; the urban “precariat”; green whatever; the black/Latino/LGBT “community”; the grassroots, the netroots, and the blogosphere; this season’s worthless Democrat; Occupy; a “Trotskyist” software engineer elected to the Seattle City Council) to another. It lacks focus and stability; its métier is bearing witness, demonstrating solidarity, and the event or the gesture. Its reflex is to “send messages” to those in power, to make statements, and to stand with or for the oppressed.

<snip>

The crucial tasks for a committed left in the United States now are to admit that no politically effective force exists and to begin trying to create one. This is a long-term effort, and one that requires grounding in a vibrant labor movement. Labor may be weak or in decline, but that means aiding in its rebuilding is the most serious task for the American left. Pretending some other option exists is worse than useless. There are no magical interventions, shortcuts, or technical fixes. We need to reject the fantasy that some spark will ignite the People to move as a mass. We must create a constituency for a left program — and that cannot occur via MSNBC or blog posts or the New York Times.

It requires painstaking organization and building relationships with people outside the Beltway and comfortable leftist groves. Finally, admitting our absolute impotence can be politically liberating; acknowledging that as a left we have no influence on who gets nominated or elected, or what they do in office, should reduce the frenzied self-delusion that rivets attention to the quadrennial, biennial, and now seemingly permanent horse races. It is long past time for us to begin again to approach leftist critique and strategy by determining what our social and governmental priorities should be and focusing our attention on building the kind of popular movement capable of realizing that vision.

Obama and his top aides punctuated that fact by making brutally apparent during the 2008 campaign that no criticism from the left would have a place in this regime of Hope and Change. The message could not be clearer.

[Scuba]

1. The left remains strong in numbers, but the left's leadership has been co-opted. We are now ....

.... seeing the backlash from that betrayal and it will only get stronger.

We have the numbers.

[Bubzer]

6. The scary thing is that the left has moved so far to the right.

It's so bad, I've heard some conservatives talking sense versus what the GOP talks about (At least, at points).
I honestly think a number of conservatives are actually pushing to the left because the right has gone so far into crazy land.

[djean111]

2. I am not giving up, nor am I resignedly joining the Third Way DNC.

Thanks for the OP!

[Bubzer]

7. Hear hear!

[merrily]

3. Thank you, Harper's Bazaar, for an indictment of Third Way and the Clinton administration.

However, as for your suggestion that the left give up and watch passively as the country gets pushed further and further right

&list=RDnvlTJrNJ5lA

[Enthusiast]

4. +1 a whole bunch!

[Enthusiast]

5. Kicked and recommended!

[MisterP]

8. the left's been trained to apologize for wanting anything