"Why Obama And Democrats Don’t Do Much of What Liberals Want "
This is realpolitik.
This is a good article with some good comments. To be a power the left has to stick together and draw our own red lines, withdrawing support if we get ignored. Pragmatism doesnt work in a war, and make no mistake, we are at war.
Scuba
(53,475 posts)Pab Sungenis
(9,612 posts)this is what they will do.
They still haven't learned the lesson of 2010.
nashville_brook
(20,958 posts)This is billed as a discussion of security practices, but the second half of the show is all about real. Right around the 30 minute mark starts this part of the discussion and they even discuss Ian Welsh's first part of this essay.
KoKo
(84,711 posts)I'll definitely download that.
I think it's long past time we need to EXAMINE...what went Wrong and What We did Correctly in the Netroots Movement.
Thanks for the LINK!
I think that airing the differing viewpoints is a "GOOD THING" about how we who Seized and Owned (We thought) the "NETROOTS" ended up not as savvy as we all thought. (Sorry Martha) but, she did have a way with words.
And, I will go to my Grave...feeling that we (Netroots) laid a Foundation for the Future...even if we Flubbed up on our early efforts.
I refuse to be a "Debbie Downer" as Ian and Jerome are. Both admit they've moved on...but those of us in the "Left Behind Crowd" know we have hard road ahead of us...but we laid the seeds for Edward Snowden and the rest upcoming to SEIZE the MOMENT. I'm perhaps making this too Inclusive...because who the heck knows what inspired Snowden...but, the seeds were planted for CHANGE.. And, we haven't lost those Green Shoots no matter which Political Op..kept looking at the PAST for their PLAYBOOK.
The NETROOTS REVOLUTION was a good thing...even though the early stages...had their hits and disappointments...it was still worth being involved in and I believe, it will morph.
That's why I thought that "Jerome's" Replies were worth a look. We are making History as we Live in it........and what comes will go down long after us. For all it's WARTS and Stop and Starts...there are so many YOUNG who saw this as their Future...and when it got "haulted" they then will take up the Baton, in whatever ways that THEY FIND...to keep going. As I said, I truly believe this...that GOOD will COME FROM OUR EFFORTS..which seems so long ago in the current news cycle.
nashville_brook
(20,958 posts)the netroots aren't going away. as a matter of fact they'll be a lot stronger with the table not being run entirely by people beholden to one candidate or another. i actually didn't know that history about Clarke vs Dean and their netroots brain trust. that's the problem right there. netroots should be advocacy and opposition (holding electeds accountable). it can't be straight-up "my candidate and no other" b/c that's no way to build power. it's a sure way to drain power, as was the case.
KoKo
(84,711 posts)for the Netroots Movement that so many of us "long time DU'ers" and "Daily Kos" Readers and Members have lived throught since "2000 Selection," and the BIRTH OF THE NETROOTS.
Jerome's somewhat badly written, but emotional History of his Personal Experience...is worth a read. Here's one Snip...and I'm just getting to Obama Campaign.
Serious Political Dem DU'ers who've been around since 2000 will find this interesting in whatever way they were involved. It gives some "inside" scoop as to the background.
SNIP from COMMENTS of "Jerome's" History as he Saw It:
--------
What Happens Next
So, when the insurgent becomes the frontrunner, Dean tries to become the establishment and win it all, starting in Iowa. And then we learned what really came next, and what Trippi didnt even want to give voice too, perhaps fearing the jinx of materialization, or maybe just not having a clue either, but I think he knew what he feared happening. And here, we are talking about 1) the splitting of the movement; 2) the murder-suicide; 3) the dancers music being turned off (you have to see the above comment I made).
Jerome Armstrong permalink
November 4, 2013
Part of the first is the Clark campaign; part of the second was done by people that included the guys that wound up making up the inner core of Obamas 08 campaign; and part of the third was done by the corporate-DC media meme.
Clark
Sometimes I wonder if the division is just a feature of the whole thing. The Clark movement is complex. There was a point in time after it was all over, when a scandal formed, by something Zephyr Teachout said about Dean and Trippi having bought out Markos and Jerome for their blogging. Zephyr was wrong about that part, but what she was really referring to (and something I fully explained when this came out) was that wed been talking with Wes Clark about his running for President. The problem was that Markos and I wanted to work together as political consultants. I had ties with Dean, he with Clark, and so we agreed that whomever hired us first is where wed go. That made the dilemma easy, or so it seemed at the time.
Back then, in 2002, I lived out in Seaside Oregon, in a wooden log-heated cabin on the banks of an estuary, from which Id kayak out into the pacific ocean during days when I was free from online trading. I was standing outside on the phone one morning, amidst the chickens, listening to Trippi say, Look, its the moment. I dont want you to be thinking 10 years from now I wish I would have taken the opportunity and not have taken it. I was thinking to myself, this sounds inspiring but it also sounds like something he might say to everyone he wants to hire but
Im in, and tell Markos Im heading out, moving the family to Vermont. But Markos doesnt quite want to give up on the Clark dream, so while we go to work for Dean, he keeps maneuvering and eventually sets up a back room meeting for Clark and Dean.
In the meantime, Maslin revs up a focus group to run the possibility of a Dean-Clark ticket. One night, as the campaign is shutting shop, Trippi asks me to stay on in his office and watch the 3 hours of tapes. Alone in HQs late into the evening, the future seems to be laid out. The possibility of teaming up an anti-war Doctor thats Governor, and a 4-star General thats progressive, just wows the dozen or so democratic primary voters assembled for the group.
Once Dean gets the gist of the focus group results, he decides that he will break convention and, months prior to the voting, ask Clark to be his VP. Markos and I buy DeanClark.com and dream of 16 years. Clark agrees to meet with Dean but wont decide on the VP role for sure. It goes back and forth but the meeting is on. Trippi told me later that the day of the meeting, Clarks guy called and asked that Dean not ask the question. But when Dean is set on something, I am pretty sure it went down with Dean asking, and Clark not committing. Only those two were in the meeting. Dean left the meeting saying its not on. Later, Clark would claim Dean asked him. Im sure he did.
The second part of this involves Hilary and the Clintons. In the fall of 2003, Armstrong-Zuniga, as our nascent firm was called, got a call from Patti Solis Doyle, about interviewing for Clinton. I had known of the Clintons since going to school in Arkansas in the mid 80′s. And despite one of my close friends being the president of the College Republicans, and having a girlfriend that worked on Clintons Little Rock Gubernatorial campaigns, I couldnt be bothered to even vote. But in 1986, I walked into the election-night hotel room full of campaign supporters the night of the election, as the couple was going on stage, and I didnt even notice Bill up on the stage, just being taken aback at the radiance around Clinton. I will digress and mention that its also the night I stepped out onto a balcony to share a joint, and walked back into the hotel penthouse amidst a small circle of guys that were spittin tobacco juice onto the carpet floor, saying crazy-ass militant and reactionary shit: a Tommy Robinson suite and crew. WTF, I thought, if this lunatic is a Democratic rep, we are doomed.
I digressed to talk about the origin of the Tea Party, and now return to Hillary Clinton and the Fall of 03, when AZ went to DC and met with Patti Solis Doyle. We were chosen with two other firms for her new media operation, and it awaited finalization. Only much later did I learn that Clinton wasnt just making a plan of setting up a team for her standing committee or whatever, but instead was putting together a team for jumping into the 04 presidential campaign. Damn, naivety strikes again. But anyway, when that didnt happen is when Clark decided to make it a go. And Clark was supplied with plenty of former Clinton-Gore staffers and Arkansas funding to make it a go. Not all, mind you, as there were definitely grassroots operations leading the way. Without that, Clark was nothing. It was just as electric at times for Clark as for Dean. But without a doubt, coming about for whatever reasons, the division of the netroots here had succeeded. It wasnt nearly as nasty as 08, but a feature, not a bug, perhaps.