Posted at the risk of being crucified or banned...

[Binkie The Clown]

Just plain not politically correct, but he asks an honest, and important question:

[DavidDvorkin]

1. I suppose this wouldn't last long in GD

It would be locked. But if it lasted, I'd be very interested to see the discussion. Given the way DU has evolved (or devolved) recently, I suspect there would be lots of support for that student and condemnation of the professor, sad to say.

[Binkie The Clown]

2. The old saying is "The devil will quote the Bible to his own ends."

IMHO Truly dangerous enemies of democracy and freedom are taking cover behind "political correctness" and using it to discourage others from exposing their beliefs, or criticizing their true aims.

And that applies to the Christian Right as well.

[onager]

6. The Horseshoe Theory in action.

Theorizes that the Far Right and Far Left aren't on opposite ends of a linear political spectrum. Instead they're located at each end of a horseshoe, and often greatly resemble each other. Especially in their authoritarian attempts to shut down free speech etc.

I'm personally starting to agree with that theory more and more. Especially as I get called into so many DU juries where someone Alerts because "that post hurt my fee-fees" or "I needed a Trigger Warning."

In fact, my current personal policy is to NEVER hide a post in what I see as free-speech cases. At this point, I'm so annoyed, I'd probably vote to Leave a post that advocated punching puppies.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory

[Promethean]

3. Its really very telling about muslim culture.

The speaker even narrowed it down for her. He said "I am a jew, the leader of Hezbollah has said he wants my people to gather in Israel so he doesn't have to hunt globally to kill us all, are you for or against him?" she answered "For." He literally got her to publicly support genocide.

[mr blur]

4. Don't worry, we don't do crucifixions in this group,

He was right and she was incredibly arrogant, self-righteous and just plain stupid.

[NeoGreen]

5. Willing to post a text summary...

... for those of us who don't have YouTube privileges while hunting for our filthy lucre?

I want to know if I should start gathering kindling for the pyre (since we apparently don't do crucifixions around here).

[trotsky]

8. Muslim student, member of MSA (Muslim Student Alliance)...

asks Horowitz to clarify why he links MSA with terrorists. He makes his point by asking her to condemn Hamas or Hezbollah. She refuses.

There's an even more gasp-worthy moment near the end, he says the leader of Hezbollah hopes that all Jews will gather in Israel, so he doesn't have "hunt (them) down" globally. And then asks her: "FOR it or AGAINST it?"

She replies: "For it."

Chilling.

[NeoGreen]

9. Eeek... very chilling...

...so I guess I will be gathering some kindling.

...sorry Binkie, messenger and all that, you'll understand, right?
So, just stand right here while we tie you to this post.
Unless you prefer to opt for The Wheel?

Plus, crucifixion is a doddle...

(posted without proofing, so I hope it is the right one)

[Lordquinton]

13. some posters here try to do this sort of thing

But when you corner them they just writhe and wriggle, then pretend you're the one not answering their question.

[edhopper]

7. But what about

all those great daycare centers?


I guess she is one of the majority peace loving Muslims who don't support the very, very few bad Muslims.

[DavidDvorkin]

10. The bad ones aren't TRUE Muslims

And they weren't born in Scotland, either.

[Binkie The Clown]

11. More to the point, she DID support the bad ones. n/t

[Curmudgeoness]

12. Another example of why religion is not warm and fuzzy.

The professor did not answer her question---he forced her to answer it herself, and I loved how he did that.

[Act_of_Reparation]

14. Ugh.

I guess I now know the answer to the question: "What would someone have to say to make David Horowitz the second-biggest asshole in the room".

I really hope she wasn't serious.

[Arugula Latte]

15. She seemed deadly serious.

Emphasis on deadly.

Not that Horowitz isn't a creep as well.

[onager]

16. Anyone else catch Whorowitz on "Bullshit?"

Not the usual bullshit, of which he is full. But the Penn & Teller show "Bullshit" on Showtime.

That's the episode that turned me right off the show. I had watched every episode, with some major eye-rolling when the Libertarian propaganda showed up. But after that one I pretty much gave up.

The topic was "Liberal Indoctrination In Colleges" and Whorowitz was at his absolute slimiest.

The show was completely one-sided, with the looniest examples of liberal "indoctrination" carefully cherry-picked.

And naturally, no mention of conservative schools like Claremont, Pepperdine or good old Bob Jones University.

[Act_of_Reparation]

17. I was first exposed to his nonsense when he was pushing for "Academic Bill of Rights"

By which he meant that no conservative should ever suffer their opinions being subjected to the rigor of academic debate.