Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why is it that even though every cell has been replaced in our body (some many times) (Original Post) triron Feb 2018 OP
Whoa. Beartracks Feb 2018 #1
Possibly because they aren't all replaced in one fell swoop, but in drib-drabs. shraby Feb 2018 #2
Reckon SOMEone's been imbibing some uber-kind David Hume lately ;) mr_lebowski Feb 2018 #3
Most neurons arent replaced. They last a lifetime. unblock Feb 2018 #4
Upgraded hardware, same software. nt Binkie The Clown Feb 2018 #5
Now If You Replaced The Brain. Would It Be You? TheMastersNemesis Feb 2018 #6
number of reasons lapfog_1 Feb 2018 #7
If you lose your mind, you don't miss it. JayhawkSD Feb 2018 #8
Ive gotta go smoke another bowl and think about all this. Canoe52 Feb 2018 #9
Part one is a good idea PJMcK Feb 2018 #10
Thats exactly the conclusion I came to! Canoe52 Feb 2018 #11

shraby

(21,946 posts)
2. Possibly because they aren't all replaced in one fell swoop, but in drib-drabs.
Tue Feb 13, 2018, 12:49 AM
Feb 2018

Gives them a chance to become a part of the same unit.

 

mr_lebowski

(33,643 posts)
3. Reckon SOMEone's been imbibing some uber-kind David Hume lately ;)
Tue Feb 13, 2018, 12:50 AM
Feb 2018

Also, I'm not sure that it's truly EVERY cell ... I think there's some nerve and brain cells that are the same ones we've literally had since the womb ...

unblock

(54,128 posts)
4. Most neurons arent replaced. They last a lifetime.
Tue Feb 13, 2018, 12:54 AM
Feb 2018

And you can experience continuity of self if entire limbs and organs go away or are transplanted, so cells being replaced elsewhere in the body hardly should matter to continuity of self

lapfog_1

(30,095 posts)
7. number of reasons
Tue Feb 13, 2018, 01:33 AM
Feb 2018

first, as one responder noted, not every cell replicates at exactly the same time...

Analogy... if you understand how computer storage devices work... there is a method which uses redundancy to ensure that information survives the loss (and replacement) of a component device. Example, consider 5 disk drives working in parallel (like brain cells)... we store 4 bits of information (bits, bytes, blocks, whatever) onto 4 drives and on the 5th we store the sum of the XOR function of the other 4 drives... ( 0 XOR 0 yields a 0, 1 XOR 1 yields a 0, 0 XOR 1 yields 1 ). Now, should one of the 4 drives fails, we swap it for a new drive (cell replicates) and rebuild the missing information by simply doing the XOR on the remaining 4 drives and writing the sum on the new drive. In the cell world that would be making the neurons connect with the cells not replicated.

How do we know the analogy holds?.. remove a piece of your brain... if it is big enough on in the right area... your personality might/will change... certain memories will be forgotten. That would be like removing more than 1 disk drive from the 5 drives. It survives the loss of 1 drive, but not 2 or more.

Second, how do you know it DOESN'T change your sense of self as cells replicate (as you age)? Time definitely changes your memories as it makes new memories... but it also might change your memory all on its own.

 

JayhawkSD

(3,163 posts)
8. If you lose your mind, you don't miss it.
Tue Feb 13, 2018, 01:55 AM
Feb 2018

Because you don't have anything to miss it with.

TheMastersNemesis raises a good point. How do you know that you actually do experience continuity of self? How you you know that who you remember yourself as being in the past is really who you were in the past?

Yes, I have photos, but those pictures are not of me, they are merely of the shell that contains me. How can I know who I was yesterday?

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Seekers on Unique Paths»Why is it that even thoug...