Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
BAM. This is spot on (Original Post) ShepKat May 2022 OP
If you're advocating for... discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #1
Sounds to me like he's advocating for... Martin Eden May 2022 #4
JFK once said... discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #11
Of course citizens shouldn't be restricted from access to their own firearms Martin Eden May 2022 #20
Just some thoughts discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #21
To answer your questions Martin Eden May 2022 #22
Thanks for the answers. So often folks in discussions on this topic can't be civil... discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #23
Registration is necessary against straw purchases and that pipeline I cited Martin Eden May 2022 #24
More info discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #25
Amending 2A would supercede FOPA Martin Eden May 2022 #26
re: "Amending 2A" discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #27
no. ShepKat May 2022 #5
There are those among us who prefer truth perversion to just plain truth. jaxexpat May 2022 #8
You say tomato... discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #12
We need to stop calling it "gun control" Cheezoholic May 2022 #6
re: We need to stop calling it "gun control" discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #16
Except that the gun-control movement boosts gun sales krispos42 May 2022 #28
Wellll, there's certainly not much hope for somebody . . . AndyS May 2022 #7
Have a nice day. discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #13
Spot on Cheezoholic May 2022 #2
thanks for posting markie May 2022 #3
In Navy Boot Camp we were issued inoperable old rifles. rickford66 May 2022 #9
I've got a couple of questions DashOneBravo May 2022 #10
Generally, the unit qualifies together, but individuals MarineCombatEngineer May 2022 #17
That's pretty cool. DashOneBravo May 2022 #18
IMO, an irrefutable argument. BobTheSubgenius May 2022 #14
More guns make us safer??? The Jungle 1 May 2022 #15
Not a fan of the nra. Don't like the leadership. discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2022 #19
ShepKat, this marine is disingenuous SYFROYH Jun 2022 #29

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
1. If you're advocating for...
Sun May 29, 2022, 06:18 AM
May 2022

...the government having the same control over citizens that the corp maintains over Marines, there is not much hope for you.

Martin Eden

(13,458 posts)
4. Sounds to me like he's advocating for...
Sun May 29, 2022, 06:30 AM
May 2022

... the government to have greater control over firearms, not every other aspect of your life that people serving in the military are subject to.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
11. JFK once said...
Sun May 29, 2022, 08:40 AM
May 2022

..."Ask not what your country can do for you. Ask what you can do for your country."

I don't agree with restricting private individuals the same way Marines are restricted by the corp. The OP didn't add much to the video in the way of his preferences for specific changes, leaving any interpretation up to the reader.

The 2013 shooting at NAVSEA IMO highlights the difficulty in viewing assault and murder as having simple solutions.

I advocate universal background checks and I have other specific opinions.

Martin Eden

(13,458 posts)
20. Of course citizens shouldn't be restricted from access to their own firearms
Sun May 29, 2022, 11:59 AM
May 2022

But IMO they should NOT have access to military assault rifles. The OP apparently was responding to someone who used the Marines as an argument against gun control, so there was some specificity to the point he was making.

2A as written is an anachronism. I'd like to see a new Amendment which guarantees the right of private ownership, while being well regulated:

Semiautomatics and large clips are banned.

Universal background checks including private sales. ANY transfer of ownership requires a background check and change in registration for the firearm. Must be reported if lost or stolen; otherwise, registered owner is complicit in any crime committed with that weapon.

Obtaing a license to own a firearm requires passing a test pertaing to handling & storing firearms, and the relevant laws .

I'm on the fence regarding the degree of restriction for concealed carry. I'm against open carry, which is more if a political statement than a legitimate need.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
21. Just some thoughts
Sun May 29, 2022, 07:07 PM
May 2022

I'm not about to argue semantics but this one point is a bit critical...

re: "...they should NOT have access to military assault rifles." They don't in general. The AR-15 is a civilian semi-auto version of the M-16. The M-16 is a military grade weapon with a top rate of fire of 700-900 rounds per minute. An AR-15 has a stated rate of fire of 45-60 rounds per minute.

Unfortunately the number of bullets required to kill is one.

There are a variety of opinions about the 2A. Why would you say it's an anachronism?

Why ban semi-autos? I'd guess close to half guns now privately owned are semi-auto. (that's maybe 150 million or more)

UBCs... I think we agree there. Registration is another matter. Just because a gun is registered doesn't mean it can't kill. Registration won't stop the insane mass shooter types.

A license to own? I'm thinking once you pass the BGC you're licensed. I do however prefer a license to carry if you plan to carry in public. I'm not a fan of what is called Constitutional Carry. I don't like open carry within town limits. IMO a lot of the OC characters are just a different version of the class clown type attention whores. Camping in the woods you can OC all you want.

Thanks for the thoughts.

Martin Eden

(13,458 posts)
22. To answer your questions
Sun May 29, 2022, 07:58 PM
May 2022

Last edited Sun May 29, 2022, 08:37 PM - Edit history (1)

2A is an anachronism because it is predicated on the "necessity" of a well regulated militia for the security of a "free state." This is no longer the late 18th century when American civilians were needed to assemble and fight conflicts with native Americans, the French, or the British.

Instead of "military weapons" I should have e specified semiautomatic. They are designed to kill more people in a shorter period of time, as are larger clips. Totally unnecessary, except as self defense against others thusly armed.

Registration and transfer of title is perhaps THE most necessary measure. The daily carnage in my hometown of Chicago is mostly carried out with firearms not registered to the perps. An illicit pipeline from Indiana and other states with more lax gun control fills the streets.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
23. Thanks for the answers. So often folks in discussions on this topic can't be civil...
Sun May 29, 2022, 08:33 PM
May 2022

...so mutual respect is really a good thing.

I do have a different view of the 2A but that can wait.

I did see that you said semi-autos at some point but I didn't take the hint that those were being equated. I don't really have a problem with semi-auto. For one thing, if you have bought a gun for self-defense, I figure you're most likely to be assaulted by someone with at least a revolver and more likely another semi-auto. With over 100 million semi-autos in the US, I also think that genie is already out of the bottle. I can't see some gang doing a drive-by with bolt action rifles. I don't own a gun now and haven't for years. IMO it's an expensive activity and me being kind of poor and rather cheap, it's not for me.

You have to explain the registration thing because I don't see how that does anything.

Good night for now. The wife and I are going to relax and watch news soon to see who shot who.

I'll check in tomorrow. Have a peaceful holiday.

Martin Eden

(13,458 posts)
24. Registration is necessary against straw purchases and that pipeline I cited
Sun May 29, 2022, 09:57 PM
May 2022

And the idea -- or the fact -- that semiautomatics are needed as defense against others armed with automatics is, to me, a very strong argument for not just banning their sale but making possession of them lllegal. Buy them back. Melt them down.

Politically and logistically difficult? No doubt, but a civilian arms race is madness and more death.

You haven't shared your view on 2A, but I will tell you one that I unequivocally reject:

The notion that firepower in civilian hands is necessary to overthrow our own government.

Most of that firepower today and the ideology with the lust to use it dwells on the extreme right. That would be a nightmare dystopia ushering in a far worse tyranny than what they believe they are fighting against.

Peace,
Martin

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
25. More info
Mon May 30, 2022, 10:50 AM
May 2022

From the FOPA of 1986:

No such rule or regulation prescribed [by the Attorney General] after the date of the enactment of the Firearms Owners Protection Act may require that records required to be maintained under this chapter or any portion of the contents of such records, be recorded at or transferred to a facility owned, managed, or controlled by the United States or any State or any political subdivision thereof, nor that any system of registration of firearms, firearms owners, or firearms transactions or disposition be established. Nothing in this section expands or restricts the Secretary's authority to inquire into the disposition of any firearm in the course of a criminal investigation.

My understanding is that this is a general provision that has specific exceptions like, AFAIK, some states register the guns that residents with concealed carry permits plan to actually carry.

Aside from all this a majority of owners and pro-RKBA folks are adamantly opposed to general registration.

As I said before probably 150 million of the guns in the US today are semi-auto. I would ballpark fair market values between $40-50 billion. That amount of money would pale in comparison to the budget involved in the collection and processing of guns recovered and the subsequent cost of prosecuting the non-compliant folks. I'd guess the cost would approach $1 trillion.


Semi-auto rifles were first invented in 1779. The idea that the Founders, some of the most intelligent, experienced and well informed people of the day, never considered semi-auto rifles when writing the 2A, is impossible to believe.

For 230+ years the 2A has stood unchanged and is accepted as a protection against government denying an individual right to keep and bear arms. State and federal courts and legislatures have deemed lawful several types of semi-auto rifles and handguns.

An amendment requires a proposal advanced by either 33 states or 357 Congresspersons and the acceptance of 401 Congresspersons or 38 states. IMO the attempt isn't worth the fallout.

I don't think there will ever be a case where civilians will work to overthrow throw the federal government. I don't see a scenario such as the events of 4 May 1970 will ever be repeated on a national or even regional scale. I believe these things by virtue of the innate character of the typical servicemen and women I know. Unlike other times in history and other areas of the world, these folks do not view themselves as separate from other citizens and of some higher class. IMO the 2A is one of the things that helps maintain that equality.

I prefer to consider measures that could be sufficiently supported as to be passed into law. Experience from the campaign against drunk driving points to the education and cooperation of the drinking public. It didn't matter if those drinking where alcoholics or just friends enjoying a night out. Programs like designated drivers and taking a taxi or Uber when drinking have helped more than all of the laws and fines of the past.

Peace to you and yours

Martin Eden

(13,458 posts)
26. Amending 2A would supercede FOPA
Mon May 30, 2022, 11:35 AM
May 2022

Passing an Amendment would require sweeping Democratic victories at the state & federal level, or a change in priorities among "conservative" voters. A substantial majority of the voting public favors universal background checks, but it doesn't top their list of issues.

Perhaps more massacres of children will turn that tide. Otherwise, the massacres will continue.

Or maybe in the next few decades the conservative Court will be replaced by a liberal one and they take a more literal interpretation of 2A, that the right us predicated on a well regulated militia.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
27. re: "Amending 2A"
Mon May 30, 2022, 12:58 PM
May 2022

IMO this is a generation or 2 in the future, if ever. Therefore, I prefer expending effort of tasks which:
* Have a chance of succeeding within a 2 year Congressional term
* Won't alienate members of my party that will be needed for meaningful accomplishments within 2 years


Side note: I favor lifting the cap on the size of the House and setting the district size equal to the population of the least populous state. The Electoral College would then follow.

jaxexpat

(7,785 posts)
8. There are those among us who prefer truth perversion to just plain truth.
Sun May 29, 2022, 07:30 AM
May 2022

It's one of the blessings of overpopulation. The aberrant becomes commonplace to the point it seems impossible to tidy up the place at all.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
12. You say tomato...
Sun May 29, 2022, 08:46 AM
May 2022

I was hoping for some specific helpful ideas. IMO making to overall US into Camp Lejeune doesn't work.
YMMV

Cheezoholic

(2,612 posts)
6. We need to stop calling it "gun control"
Sun May 29, 2022, 06:49 AM
May 2022

"control" is the language that the arms dealers love. The narrative needs to be refrained as gun "safety". And base safety regulations on NRA protocols before the fucking arms dealers took it over in the 70's. My grandfather disowned them in 1979 and he was about as conservative as you could get back then. He burned my NRA card also. The NRA was about safety before the arms dealers gained control in a hostile takeover in 77. Thats what they are now, the political front for US arms dealers. Smith and Wesson got sick of companies like Raytheon et. al. making millions in weapons contracts while they were saddled with deer hunters. None of this is about the 2nd amendment, 0. It's about American small arms manufactures becoming arms dealers and cashing in. They could care less. As long as they can hide behind the 2nd by scaring fuck heads they'll lose their guns they will continue to unabashedly flood this country with weapons legally. Its all about the cash man.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
16. re: We need to stop calling it "gun control"
Sun May 29, 2022, 09:18 AM
May 2022

We sure do. Not only arms dealers but many pro-restriction folks as well. The word control is a lie. The only real control for humans is self-control. Having laws termed as "gun control" gives those in favor of restrictions the idea that laws will stop people from being violent. They play into the hands of a lot of politicians. The job of your political representatives is to be instruments of their constituency. However, IMO legislators have the responsibility of adding wisdom to the will of the people.

The primary use of laws is to provide a criteria in court to convict a criminal. Laws against murder and violent personal attack aren't called homicide control or assault control. Of course honest people will avoid breaking laws. Those folks have self-control.

I advocate most these days for universal background checks. One reason for that is that last I checked background checks on private sales (non-dealers at gun shows, neighbors, relatives and unknown folks meeting on the Walmart parking lot) are illegal in 28 states.

It's a business, of course it's about cash.

krispos42

(49,445 posts)
28. Except that the gun-control movement boosts gun sales
Tue May 31, 2022, 11:26 AM
May 2022

Yeah, maybe in some states they can't sell "assault weapons" (by whatever definition the state uses) but they definitely boost gun sales.




I did an entire thread on it a few months ago: https://www.democraticunderground.com/1172211325

But the crux of it is, gun owners know that the idea of "assault weapons" is arbitrary and emotional and based on things like... a protruding pistol grip or a buttstock that adjusts without tools. This is because, shockingly, gun owners knows about guns pretty intimately and non-gun-owners don't.

Once you can ban "assault weapons" you can expand the definition to cover most anything.

To be brutally honest, if I was a gun maker that sold guns in America, I would secretly funnel a few hundred thousand a year to American anti-gun groups. I mean, look at the graph! Mere advertising can't triple the market for guns like fears of government bans does!

rickford66

(5,664 posts)
9. In Navy Boot Camp we were issued inoperable old rifles.
Sun May 29, 2022, 07:53 AM
May 2022

We still had to treat them as loaded weapons. God help you if you cocked it and pulled the trigger. That "click" sound would get you a full day of punishment.

DashOneBravo

(2,679 posts)
10. I've got a couple of questions
Sun May 29, 2022, 08:39 AM
May 2022

For the Marines on here.

How does the 2 week work?

Every Marine gets pulled to go the range individually?

The unit goes together?

MarineCombatEngineer

(14,322 posts)
17. Generally, the unit qualifies together, but individuals
Sun May 29, 2022, 09:56 AM
May 2022

can qualify/practice under strict supervision of the range master and firing line NCO.

BobTheSubgenius

(11,789 posts)
14. IMO, an irrefutable argument.
Sun May 29, 2022, 08:54 AM
May 2022

A damned good thing this kind of thinking wasn't applied when the 2nd Amendment was reinterpreted in the 70s, huh? A damned good thing for the NRA, gun manufacturers, psychopaths and gun-humping wannabes.

 

The Jungle 1

(4,552 posts)
15. More guns make us safer???
Sun May 29, 2022, 09:08 AM
May 2022

So why were there no guns at the nra party of sick perversion.
Trump should have demanded guns be there so he would be safe! More guns make him safer, RIGHT!
Just ignore the dead babies, they don't count.
We do need better mental health care in this country. The entire nra membership needs mental health care.

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,576 posts)
19. Not a fan of the nra. Don't like the leadership.
Sun May 29, 2022, 10:55 AM
May 2022

re: "So why were there no guns at the nra party..."
Generally the venue owners and operators set the rules. Your venue (home, car, storefront, boxing ring...) your choice to allow otherwise lawful possession. Some hotels don't allow dogs. Some apartments don't allow large water containing appliances.

trump is a dangerous jackass.

SYFROYH

(34,201 posts)
29. ShepKat, this marine is disingenuous
Sun Jun 5, 2022, 09:23 AM
Jun 2022

He asks why the Marines on base cant keel there private weapons even though they test once a year?

He knows the answer. His base is circled by tall fence with barbed wire (twice), patroled constantly by armed teams of marines with fully automatic rifles, and gates screen people coming and going sometimes with armed persons and sometimes K-9s.

In other words the marine corps is taking responsibility for everyone’s safety.

We cant even trust the police to enter a school to stop an active shooter.
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»BAM. This is spot on