American History
Related: About this forumWho are your top five American Presidents?
My list:
1. Abraham Lincoln
2. George Washington
3. Franklin Delano Roosevelt
4. John Adams
5. Barack Obama
hlthe2b
(106,237 posts)Might we have gone to war over the Cuban missile crisis? Would we have ever gone to the moon and reaped all the technological advances? Would the road to civil rights for AA been further delayed?
I think that BO may well earn a place in the top five, with a second term. I certainly have great hopes.
Of course, I would have FDR on there--no question. Washington, yup, Lincoln, absolutely.
I'd have to think about the fifth spot...
UrbScotty
(23,987 posts)CountAllVotes
(21,048 posts)1. JFK
2. FDR
3. TR
4. Abraham Lincoln
5. ...
limpyhobbler
(8,244 posts)These are just my favorites. Not saying they were the Best. It's based things including personality.
1. FDR
2. Lincoln
3. Teddy Roosevelt
4. LBJ
5. Harry Truman
ellisonz
(27,737 posts)mrmpa
(4,033 posts)Franklin Roosevelt
Teddy Roosevelt
Harry Truman
Barack Obama
Woodrow Wilson
shcrane71
(1,721 posts)hmmm probably:
FDR
Lincoln
Teddy Roosevelt
John Addams
Jimmy Carter
TheKentuckian
(26,028 posts)FDR
Lincoln
TDR
Truman
Washington
amandabeech
(9,893 posts)Lincoln
FDR
Washington
Teddy R
Jefferson
Very Honorable Mention: Truman and Wilson
I want to read some of the new biographies of Ike. He may have been a much more subtle manipulator for the common good the scenes, and he did end the Korean War.
bemildred
(90,061 posts)Obama is a story not finished yet.
Mostly I consider them a sorry lot. Jimmy is the only one since WWII I have any real respect for.
kag
(4,106 posts)I think my list would go something like...
FDR
Washington
JFK
Madison
LBJ
Obama is, like others have said, a bit incomplete. And I have to exclude Lincoln because of the whole "If I could save the Union without freeing a single slave..." line. He would be in my top ten, but not top five because I think deep down he was a racist.
Buzz cook
(2,583 posts)"He would be in my top ten, but not top five because I think deep down he was a racist."
You exclude Lincoln because he "might" be a racist, but include two slave owners who were undoubtedly racist.
Good job including LBJ though. Too many people forget how much we owe to the Great Society.
kag
(4,106 posts)Lincoln's claim to greatness rests largely with his having emancipated the slaves. And, frankly, even though I believe he was a racist, he would still make my top ten since freeing the slaves was still a "great" thing to do, no matter what was in his heart. I just think that among great presidents some others might eclipse him for reasons that have to do with things other than slavery.
Washington and Madison were instrumental in creating the United States in the first place. I think that's pretty great. BTW, So was Jefferson, who would also make my top ten. But Jefferson was a pretty sleazy politician, and an overall weird guy.
But that's just my opinion...
pscot
(21,037 posts)Truman was the last, maybe the only, peoples President. He was one of us.
sarisataka
(20,930 posts)Washington- the infant country could have been stillborn. he showed that the new federal republic would work
Lincoln- despite some failings he kept the country together in its greatest challenge
FDR- brought the country out of the depression. Saw the U.S. As a player on the world stage equal to any of the traditional powers
Truman- a man of the people. Made what was probably the single hardest decision any president has made. Use the bombs which will surely kill thousands or not and risk millions upon invading Japan.
Wilson- a master diplomat who saw where the world was going,decades before anyone else. He is not fully appreciated even today.
Honorable Mentions- JFK- inspired his generation and beyond. LBJ- Kennedy was a tough act to follow, his contributions are lost in the shadow of JFK's charisma.
Earth495
(15 posts)-Eisenhower
-FDR
-LBJ
-JFK
-Teddy Roosevelt
Christian23
(2 posts)1. George Washington
2. Franklin D. Roosevelt
3. Bill Clinton
4. Ronald Reagan
5. Abraham Lincoln
hootinholler
(26,449 posts)Really???
Please elaborate, I'd love to hear why.
LeftishBrit
(41,302 posts)susanlinch
(17 posts)1. George Washington
2. Abraham Lincoln
3. Franklin Delano Roosevelt
4. LBJ
and the 5:
KFC(not JFK)
LeftishBrit
(41,302 posts)I just looked up a list of American presidents, and there was no one with those initials. I can't even think of a president in fiction with those initials, though I may be being dim.