The Cass Report: Anti-science and Anti-trans

[LostOne4Ever]

Sorry one more Cass Review article from me. This time from Skepchick Rebecca Watson a famous Skeptic known for her science advocacy!

The Cass Report: Anti-science and Anti-trans
Rebecca Watson

This post contains a video, which you can also view here. To support more videos like this, head to patreon.com/rebecca!

For several months now, many of you have contacted me here on YouTube or on Patreon to ask my thoughts about the “Cass Report,” the slang term for the “Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People” commissioned by the UK’s National Health Services in order to guide their recommendations for kids who want gender-affirming care. We colloquially call it the “Cass Report” because the lead author was Hilary Cass, a past president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health.

The report took several years to compile, and the final result was published in April of this year. The NHS used preliminary findings in the report to guide some decisions, like halting the use of puberty blockers in kids with gender dysphoria. Because surprisingly, the conclusions of this seemingly very detailed nearly 400-page report was to recommend the exact opposite of the current global standards recommended by organizations like The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association, and every other major medical organization in the US.

Because the Cass Report recommended psychiatric care instead of medical interventions, it was largely embraced by transphobes around the world, who cited it as proof that treating kids with gender dysphoria is ultimately some kind of child abuse. And because I’ve talked in the past about the scientific basis for the current consensus that gender-affirming care is good actually, a lot of you were wondering if this report changed my mind.

[…]

If you’re wondering why a systematic review this biased and poorly edited would be written, accepted, published, and used to guide public policy, I recommend this article from Mother Jones, published back in May, that summarizes what we now know about the making of the Cass Report.

[…]

More at link:
https://skepchick.org/2024/06/the-cass-report-anti-science-and-anti-trans/

Cross linked to the Science and Skepticism group!

[LostOne4Ever]

1. I love her concluding remarks!

It’s a total coincidence but the last few times I’ve put out a video defending the current consensus on the treatment of children and young people with gender dysphoria, I happen to have been on vacation and away from the internet. And each time I’ve come home to find an avalanche of angry comments from frothing transphobes who crow that my not responding to them is proof that I don’t respect them, as opposed to proof that I was just not on the internet. Well, this time I don’t have a vacation planned, so I want the transphobes to know that THIS time, I’m not responding because I do not respect you in the least.

[wolfie001]

2. I know there's a lot of JK Rowling fans on here but......

......her cryptic tweets on the subject are hateful bigotry. Pretending to be so downtrodden while being one of the richest people in Britain. I find her repulsive. Tell me the wealthy who think like her didn't basically write this rubbish. Plus, the Daily Mail and Rupert Murdoch Oh well, just my take on the whole mess.

[Kalifornia9]

3. Just an amusing aside:

Notably that religious wackjob organizations get their panties all in a bunch that LGBT people exist. My brother lives near Colorado Springs, visiting him, I was a bit dismayed that "Focus on the Family" not only has it's own freeway exit, but it looks like a cult compound, surrounded with prison style razor wire fencing and all.
My brother mentioned that a popular bumper sticker seen in the area read "Focus on Your Own Damn Family".