Republicans keep gerrymandered maps - after they were struck down by court

[cbabe]

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jul/21/ohio-republicans-gerrymandered-maps

Republicans keep gerrymandered maps – after they were struck down by court

Ohio Republicans have maneuvered to keep legislative maps in place for this fall’s election despite the state supreme court striking them down seven times this year

Sam Levine in New York
Thu 21 Jul 2022 06.00 EDT

…

Turcer is the executive director of the Ohio chapter of Common Cause, a government watchdog group, and one of the most knowledgeable people about redistricting in her state. Earlier that morning, the Ohio supreme court struck down the map for the state’s 15 congressional districts, saying they were so distorted in favor of Republicans that they violated the state constitution. It was the seventh time this year the court has struck down either a congressional or state legislative map this year (it has struck down the congressional map twice and state legislative districts five times).

Despite those rulings, Republicans have maneuvered to keep both the congressional and state legislative maps in place for this fall’s election. It has set up an extraordinary circumstance in Ohio: voters will cast ballots for federal and state representation this fall in districts that are unconstitutional.

Turcer and I have spoken several times over the last few months as the saga in Ohio has unfolded, and she is not someone who sugar coats things. I’ve been interested in her perspective as someone who was initially optimistic about the reforms – she fought to pass them – but has seen the reality of how Republicans have brazenly ignored them this year.

…

Now, Ohio Republicans have validated that criticism. In both their congressional and state legislative maps, they’ve sought maps that would give them a huge advantage, and have passed their plans on partisan lines. Each time the supreme court has rejected their efforts, they’ve only made marginal tweaks and submitted the plan again. Eventually, they ran out the clock, forcing courts to allow their maps to go into effect this year.

…

“We should have fought harder over leaving the Ohio redistricting in charge of mapmaking,” Turcer told me. “It seems really clear that giving the Ohio supreme court the stick, shall we say, not just the carrot, could have made an enormous difference.”

After seeing the reforms fail, Turcer said she expects a push to create an independent redistricting commission in Ohio, something that the chief justice of the Ohio supreme court, the critical swing vote in all of the redistricting cases, has encouraged.

“It certainly hasn’t worked the way it should. The mapmakers are just drunk on power. And you take away the keys from drunks,” she said. Clearly, the next step is an independent, insulated commission.”

[Irish_Dem]

1. The GOP doesn't have to follow the law.

The laws are to protect them and to control others.

[TheRealNorth]

2. Yup

Empires have fallen when the guilty go free and the innocent are punished.

[Irish_Dem]

3. Yes exactly. I never actually thought I would see the US crumble away into fascism.

Not in my lifetime.

[No Vested Interest]

4. It seems to me that the results of this election could be contested after the election,

inasmuch as the map has been declared illegal.
Interested parties, individuals or groups could sue the state.

Perhaps could prevent the winners from taking their seats in January.