Only one can stay--Green Bean Casserole. Candied Sweet potatoes, NO marshallows. jello salad. or

[debm55]

canned jelled cranberries.

[Glorfindel]

1. Canned jelled cranberries for me.

I love the stuff.

[debm55]

3. Thank you Glorindel.

[CrispyQ]

2. If candied sweet potatoes are made without marshmallows, I'll have that. Otherwise, I'll pass on all of it. -nt

[debm55]

5. GrispyQ no marshmallows. Thank you.

[Batshit_Bruin_CA]

4. Green bean casserole -version with fresh beans, almonds, sour cream

And fresh mushrooms.
If you post a poll, we could maybe vote on this fun question?

[debm55]

6. Thank you Batshit Bruin. I will have to check out making a poll. Used to do on on the older version. .

[hlthe2b]

7. Green Bean Casserole-- a little dab will do ya, but it is not loaded with sugar, unlike the rest (fat, yes)

I realize the others are "classics" but knowing there is going to be all those desserts later, I just don't get including too much sugary food at dinner. Now plain sweet potatoes with a bit of butter, yeah. But not the ooey gooey candied ones. And cranberries are interesting to me. I'm not sure I've ever eaten them no matter what form they come in. Not that I would not like them, mind you, but it always just seemed an oversight to me.

[debm55]

8. Thank you very much Hlthe2b. I agree. Would take the green been casserole.too.

[Niagara]

9. No turkey?

It would depend on who's making the side dishes and the entire ingredients list.

I would say the canned jelly cranberry would stay without knowing any of the above.



P.S. I love marshmallows, especially campfire and broiler roasted marshmallows.

[debm55]

11. Thank you Niagara. Turkey is coming in another post.

[LoisB]

10. Sweet potatoes for sure.

[debm55]

12. thank you LoisB.

[liberalla]

13. Cranberries!

[debm55]

14. Thank you , liberalla.

[Elessar Zappa]

15. Sweet potatoes.

[debm55]

29. Thank you Elessar Zappa. I like them cooked like a baked potato, not all marshmallowed up.

[Elessar Zappa]

35. I don't put marshmallows but

after roasting them, I put a stick of butter, some brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg in a pot and simmer all that for about 15 minutes, then I pour it over the sweet potatoes.

[ProfessorGAC]

16. Cranberries

Though it was hard to pass on the sweet potatoes.
I can't eat turkey without the cranberries.

[debm55]

28. We either. the next day I even put them on my turkey sandwich Thank you ProfessorGAC

[justaprogressive]

17. Green Bean Casserole. Asiago Cheese. Cream. Portobello Mushrooms. Sliced Pecans

Campbell's is not cooking

[debm55]

27. thank you justaprogressive. that sounds deliecious.

[Clouds Passing]

18. Green bean casserole

in a creamy onion & vegetable soup base. Vegan. With crunchy fried onions on top!

Can I have two? Love jellied cranberry sauce, low sugar if I can find it.

[debm55]

25. Clouds Passing I eat those fried onions on their own. HAHAHAHHAHHH

[Clouds Passing]

39. Awesome on salads 😋

[sakabatou]

19. Candied sweet potatoes can go away

[debm55]

24. Thank you sakabatou.

[Different Drummer]

20. Tough call between the green bean casserole and canned jellied cranberries.

However, I'm going with the cranberries.

[debm55]

23. Good choice Different Drummer. Thank you.

[arkielib]

21. green bean casserole

I do really like it, but the main reason I would keep it is my sister always brings it for the family Thanksgiving - which is always at my house. One less dish I have to worry about.

[debm55]

22. Arkielib, thank you very much.

[Phoenix61]

26. They can all go. nt

[Luciferous]

31. I agree, I don't like any of those.

[debm55]

32. thank you Phoenix61. All opinions are accepted here.

[Meadowoak]

30. green bean casserole, with the crispy onions on top.

[debm55]

33. Thank you Meadowoak. Love,love, love those Frenches crispy onions.

[Americanme]

34. Green bean casserole

I love that stuff.

[Ilikepurple]

36. Green bean casserole. The rest can go back to the store.

[HoosierDebbie]

37. Canned Jellied Cranberries

I definitely like the cranberry option. I even sometimes eat them on other occasions. I don't like any of the other choices, so this was an easy question to answer.

[wryter2000]

38. Sweet potatoes

As long as there are no marshmallows

[PoindexterOglethorpe]

41. Okay, so marshmallows with sweet potatoes is truly an abomination.

I personally consider jello salad to be re-gurgitated vomit, although apparently other people like it.

But WHY should anyone have to get rid of things they like???

[Dogdirt]

42. If one had to go....

If one had to go it would definitely be the family member(s) that voted forTrump

[Emile]

43. Stay--Green Bean Casserole

[happybird]

44. The canned cranberry sauce

It is a must have. Creamed spinach and mashed potatoes can substitute for the others, but nothing can replace that weird cranberry goodness.

[ailsagirl]

45. Candied sweet potatoes

[electric_blue68]

46. Forget those Gimme bread stuffing w sage instead! 😄

Maaaybe the candied sweet potatoes (looked up recipe if there's less sugar, barely, or no cinimon, definitely butter and 🩷 maple syrup)
Or
Green bean cassorole
Having read those recipes reminds me to see if Trader Joe's will have their can of ?crispy fried onions for The Holidays! 😄
Yuuuum. Snack on them for days.

[sarge43]

47. Green Bean Casserole

I'm from the Midwest. It's one of our four basic food groups.

[Emile]

48. So true 😂

[Emile]

49. The more french fried onions the better it tastes.

[sarge43]

50. No such thing as too many french fried onions n/t

[IA8IT]

55. Yes Please

[rainy]

51. Sweet potatoes

[OLDMDDEM]

52. Candied sweet potatoes.

[wendyb-NC]

53. Canned Jelled Cranberries

It wouldn't be Thanks Giving without them. Besides, they will go well with my vegetarian Thanks Giving feast.

[Basso8vb]

54. Canned jellied cranberries for me.

[orangecrush]

56. Green bean casserole