AI Translations Are Adding 'Hallucinations' to Wikipedia Articles
Source: 404 Media
Wikipedia editors have implemented new policies and restricted a number of contributors who were paid to use AI to translate existing Wikipedia articles into other languages after they discovered these AI translations added AI hallucinations, or errors, to the resulting article.
The new restrictions show how Wikipedia editors continue to fight the flood of generative AI across the internet from diminishing the reliability of the worlds largest repository of knowledge. The incident also reveals how even well-intentioned efforts to expand Wikipedia are prone to errors when they rely on generative AI, and how theyre remedied by Wikipedias open governance model.
The issue in this case starts with an organization called the Open Knowledge Association (OKA), a non-profit organization dedicated to improving Wikipedia and other open platforms.
-snip-
Wikipedia editors investigated how OKA was operating and found that it was mostly relying on cheap labor from contractors in the Global South, and that these contractors were instructed to copy/paste articles to popular LLMs to produce translations.
-snip-
Read more: https://www.404media.co/ai-translations-are-adding-hallucinations-to-wikipedia-articles/
No surprise that this went badly.
The article mentions a job posting from OKA offering $397/mo for working up to 40 hours a week, translating as many as 20 articles per week. OKA originally instructed its translators to use Grok, but has since changed that recommendation to other chatbots.
Any of which can also hallucinate at any time.
Martin68
(27,490 posts)this environment, and there are many who would love to subvert and corrupt the site.
erronis
(23,471 posts)Free knowledge has been contrary to those in power and to those that want to control it. Think of the religions over the centuries that restricted access to knowledge to the privileged few.
I am so glad to have Wikipedia available at my fingertips whenever I need it. I keep an offline copy (kiwix) just in case those types try to shut it down. (And I regularly contribute $s and sometimes a few additions/corrections.)
Wednesdays
(22,322 posts)Wouldn't that have to take several petabytes of storage?
nilram
(3,532 posts)DU is wanting to change this to an emoji, so remove the space in front of Database and you'll get to their own article on this.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia: Database_download
quaint
(4,924 posts)I do not donate to many, now one less.
nilram
(3,532 posts)erronis
(23,471 posts)quaint
(4,924 posts)I am so very sorry I offended you. You offended me by assuming it was other than a mistake.
quaint
(4,924 posts)I am very sorry to have offended you.
Prairie Gates
(7,800 posts)We need to stop using this idiotic language of "hallucination." They are not people. They are not hallucinating. They are data processing machines generating systematic error or operating systematically to generate disinformation.
Let's stop agreeing to the language of the Silicon Valley AI bros.
erronis
(23,471 posts)How about brain farts?
Prairie Gates
(7,800 posts)People understand what errors are. The question is why AI propaganda pretends that people don't.