McCarthy demands work requirements on 'all the programs' including Social Security, Medicare, Medic
This discussion thread was locked as off-topic by MustLoveBeagles (a host of the Latest Breaking News forum).
Source: raw story
McCarthy demands work requirements on ‘all the programs’ including Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and SNAP
David Badash, The New Civil Rights Movement
May 16, 2023, 1:56 PM ET
..........McCarthy also claimed that forcing people who may not be physically or emotionally able to work, or who may have responsibilities that preclude them from leaving the house to go to a job "helps the supply chain."
What the Speaker is ignoring are the millions of undocumented immigrants currently within our borders desperate to work at jobs that won't threaten their ability to stay in the country – not to mention the thousands of others coming to the U.S. seeking asylum or a way out of poverty, gangs, drugs, disease, and corruption........
.............Despite McCarthy's apparent implication that Americans accessing social safety net benefits are not currently working, in fact many who are, do.
Earlier this year the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities published a state-by-state report that also finds nationally, more than 41% of SNAP recipients are in working families................
Read more: https://www.rawstory.com/mccarthy-demands-work-requirements-on-all-the-programs-including-social-security-medicare-medicaid-and-snap/
Link to tweet
?s=20
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
BigmanPigman
(55,137 posts)work each day as the fame POTUS? I think it was 2-3 hours a day, at the most. He spent more time tweeting and trying to hide his lack of hair each day than he ever did "working" in DC. The party of Grand Old Hypocrites.
jpak
(41,780 posts)Yup
OhioTim
(389 posts)for a new debt limit when Trump was in office. No deal with the fraudsters.
electric_blue68
(26,856 posts)
chillfactor
(7,694 posts)how in the hell am I supposed to meet work requirements?
3Hotdogs
(15,368 posts)Everyone could spend at least one hour a week, stuffing envelopes at the local office of the R.N.C.
Abigail_Adams
(333 posts)who recently turned 100. He can barely walk. Just like you, what the hell is my client supposed to do? This is insane, and McCarthy is following the orders of the Chaos Caucus of the GOP whose votes he needed to become speaker. This is despicable. 
newdayneeded
(2,493 posts)I'm picturing you in the construction sector. Maybe roofing, or 10 hour days hanging siding on houses, perhaps the mining industry.....
of course I'm kidding. Mccarthy needs to pound sand! What a dickhead!
Staph
(6,467 posts)How is he supposed to meet the work requirement?
riversedge
(80,808 posts)There was no money to provide care for her and a nursing home was too expensive. She needed Medicaid and some food stamps. When I quit work she was 85 and just died a few months ago. She was a strong women-actually moved about the house with her walker until the last week. McCarthy is a cruel man. Simple as that.
Beachnutt
(8,909 posts)snap benefits and emegency medicaid are being discussed though.
If They force work requirements for food stamps (snap, supplemental nutrition assistance program)
which I hope they do not, surely more folks will show up and vote the rethugs out in the next election.
another link on this also
https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/15/gop-work-requirement-demands-debt-talks-00097058
True Blue American
(18,579 posts)And invested in SS and are still paying for Medicare. I also worked past retirement age so I could save and invest.
Now look what Republicans under DeWine and LaRosa are trying to sneak through in Ohio.
https://ohiocapitaljournal.com/2023/05/16/save-the-date-ohios-aug-8-election-puts-nearly-175-years-of-majority-voter-authority-on-the-line/
jaxexpat
(7,794 posts)I wonder how many people don't know the difference between the concept of a "social safety net" and the actual concrete fact of "The US Social Security Administration." I'm afraid the answer to that question will be an eye-opener and such a title does nothing but further confuse the issue.
oldsoftie
(13,538 posts)Not people with kids at home or anyone disabled.
But why not require it for single people who are able?
But these SYSTEMS also need changing. Section 8 housing assistance is rigged to give NO incentive to work more or make more money. If you make $50 more one month they'll take away $50 from your subsidy the next month. Thats BS. Maybe take away $1 for every 3-4 extra you make. Otherwise, why bother? And they stay stuck.
Not sure if SNAP does the same but it wouldn't surprise me
RegulatedCapitalistD
(416 posts)Single Able-bodied people collecting FoodStamps are already working. They are called the Working Poor
This is just smoke and mirror for the audience....political theater
GB_RN
(3,560 posts)The work requirements thing is a moneymaker for for-profit companies, not government entities. It’s a complete scam. These outfits aren’t out to help the beneficiaries of the social programs. They exist only to make a buck off of the backs of the people they allegedly “help” and us taxpayers.
The head of the biggest and oldest company (started with the original work requirements with “Welfare Reform” 1.0 in 1994), made $6 million last year and according to the clip of his first quarter earnings conference call Marketplace played, he sees massive growth potential in “Welfare Reform 2.0”. Which simply means massive growth in his compensation and stock price…and ripping off of US taxpayers. Wouldn’t the money those companies get paid be better utilized going directly to program beneficiaries? 🤬
Fuck McQarthy.
Response to oldsoftie (Reply #21)
RegulatedCapitalistD This message was self-deleted by its author.
The Jungle 1
(4,552 posts)I wonder how much corporate welfare is being cut?
Beachnutt
(8,909 posts)in that article either, Social safety program is not social security, it's food stamps, medicare, section 8 housing etc..
If they did cut that the able bodied magaloons wouldn't have time or means to attend rallies...
I don't want this to happen as it is proven to help families.
jaxexpat
(7,794 posts)There's something wrong when we quote the titles of articles when the article doesn't agree with the title. It's called misinformation and when it's repeated it's called propaganda.
Alexander Of Assyria
(7,839 posts)Another distorted article…for clickbait and ofc to generate RAGE, as work req. is focused on social safety net.
Clear?
Emile
(42,284 posts)did they impose on the bankers?
BigOleDummy
(2,274 posts)And well said.
MissMillie
(39,652 posts)Where is the requirement for business to compensate workers for higher productivity?
If wages kept pace w/ productivity, the minimum wage would be over $20/hr!
If wages were higher, tax collections would be too!
Trenzalore
(2,575 posts)My brother is severely autistic. He is in a group home with about four other mentally challenged people. The social security benefit that he receives and they receive is used to partly pay for the group home.
No employer wants to employ these people. They require aid and constant supervision.
tavernier
(14,443 posts)that the republican congress does. In that case the requirements would be “Sit on your fat ass and collect a paycheck.”
mountain grammy
(29,035 posts)How about you do some work?
Novara
(6,115 posts)One word: inequality.
Other countries with strong social support do not have the kind of violence we have. They take care of their citizens. People here get desperate, can't pay for medical care, can't provide for their families.
And republicans want to make it worse, always.
For as long as I live, I will never understand how people vote for these motherfuckers and vote against their own self-interest every goddamn time.
Easterncedar
(6,267 posts)The Welfare-to Work-Industrial Complex on The Uncertain Hour podcast. Episodes 5 and 6 need to be heard by everyone and shouted from the rooftops. McCarthy’s corruptly serving these companies that literally refer to people on welfare as their “product.” Maximus CEO admitted it might sound bad but that’s just the fact.
bucolic_frolic
(55,133 posts)Puppyjive
(987 posts)Do you know how much money it would cost to monitor work requirements? Does he think those employees at social security have the hours in the day to add that to they're plate? Their inability to govern has caused the perfect storm at social security. There won't be anyone left to manage benefits. They are losing 1000 employees a month. No one wants to work the jobs. They have become too difficult to learn and the workload is unsustainable. Good grief.
Lonestarblue
(13,479 posts)women the economic assistance needed to feed those children. When you have too many children, you can’t work because someone has to take care of them and paid child care is often unaffordable even for families with decent paying jobs. It oh so pro life to force more poor kids into the world and then refuse to feed them.
lastlib
(28,260 posts)RegulatedCapitalistD
(416 posts)It solves nothing ....its political theater
Auggie
(33,148 posts)looking for something, anything, outrageous and divisive to hang their hats on and engage followers.
tanyev
(49,288 posts)like me and all my Republican colleagues."
Vinca
(53,991 posts)physically able, just to put food on the table.
The Jungle 1
(4,552 posts)That is MY money. I paid my money into the system for 45 years. Shut your fing pie hole and give me MY money.
Next they will want a work requirement for public education. We need to put them rug rats to work.
MiHale
(13,032 posts)And on top of it they don’t care. “Representative” what a joke title they can’t represent what they don’t know.
Fiendish Thingy
(23,227 posts)McCarthy did not specify Medicare or SS- that is rawstory’s assumption, not a direct quote.
He did say “all the programs” in the context of means tested programs such as Medicaid and SNAP.
SS and Medicare are not means tested.
infullview
(1,129 posts)
Marthe48
(23,175 posts)Most of the people I know who get social security are using their time to help others. for free. Babysitting, petsitting, driving, tending. Some get low-paying jobs to augment their s.s. Actually, my group of friends are so busy, we have trouble meeting up for lunch once in awhile because we are all so busy. ass will never understand that the dynamics in many families employ the elderly, the infirm, or the young to cover what needs to be done. The r's who think we are not contributing need to get off their asses and do their jobs, instead of acting like winning an election is the culmination of their effort and they can sit on their asses and rake in tax dollars as their reward. Like that isn't entitlement? They should be paid by the hour, and be on a time clock.
IronLionZion
(51,267 posts)
groundloop
(13,846 posts)Cutting corporate welfare to big oil, corporate farms, big pharma, etc. etc. etc. would go a long way towards balancing the budget asshole!!!!
PortTack
(35,820 posts)Demands
MustLoveBeagles
(16,399 posts)As this is an opinion piece. I suggest reposting in General Discussion.