General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsArizona toddler declared dead after near-drowning was alive for hours in 'cold room', records say
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jul/07/phoenix-toddler-alive-hospitalOfficers say they saw signs of life multiple times, and after hospital treated the child, he was taken to hospital's morgue
Two Gilbert police officers saw possible signs of life multiple times, but the child was still taken to the hospital's "cold room" after being treated by staff, according to the documents.
"Please do your thing and let me do my thing," Dr Aryan Toosi told an officer at one point, according to the report. "I went to medical school for a reason."
First responders were dispatched to the home at about 5.30pm on 8 February in response to a reported drowning. They performed life-saving measures on the child before taking him to a hospital where the boy was pronounced dead about an hour later.
About five hours later, police were notified that the child was indeed breathing, and he was flown to another hospital. The boy ultimately survived and has been released.
. . .
senseandsensibility
(26,144 posts)but wow. Scary story.
calimary
(91,653 posts)Maru Kitteh
(32,151 posts)Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Cheating Death has a chapter devoted to hypothermia and induced hypothermia and the role it can play in saving life in instances of trauma.
LisaL
(48,176 posts)getting the "cold therapy" in the morgue.
Maru Kitteh
(32,151 posts)that saves you.
But yeah, not a recommended method of reducing ones metabolic demands, for sure.
pnwmom
(110,350 posts)struggle4progress
(127,354 posts)erronis
(25,133 posts)is striking. They're covering up for their own inadequacies by using medical and legal coverage. And they'll hope that the story will die quietly and they can go on about BUSINESS as usual.
Deuxcents
(28,427 posts)MustLoveBeagles
(18,560 posts)CaliforniaPeggy
(157,366 posts)It was in the OP.
Deuxcents
(28,427 posts)LisaL
(48,176 posts)I can't find any recent updates.
LisaL
(48,176 posts)I haven't seen any recent updates indicating his current condition. Per the gofundme from back in February, he definitely was not released home the same day. He was breathing with an assistance of a ventilator.
CaliforniaPeggy
(157,366 posts)LisaL
(48,176 posts)Gofundme set up back in February claimed he was going to need extensive therapy. But it provided no updates.
BannonsLiver
(21,152 posts)milestogo
(23,423 posts)tasks of being a doctor.
lonely bird
(3,144 posts)There is something called mammalian diving response. Perhaps that was involved?
fierywoman
(8,676 posts)he was flying (a biplane). He was declared dead. His sister -- a nurse -- went to see his body in the morgue and realized he was still alive. He lived to be in his early 70s. And so I am here...
Melon
(1,994 posts)That boy was a for an hour. In some cases extremely cold water can play a crucial role as a mammalian diving reflex can clamp the larynx closed and slow respiration and heart rate. This is why you are not suppose to declare death unless they are warm and dead. This drowning was in phoenix so cold couldnt have played a role. A body of someone brain dead can absolutely move or jerk or gasp even though they are medically dead. This is obviously malpractice from the doctor. They should be checking the brain for any sign of life.
In my situation, we were able to get the childs heart beating again, but his brain was gone and there was no saving him. Perhaps there was a bit of luck putting this baby in the cold room. This is the exact treatment that can be used for child drowning victims to limit brain damage and brain/organ swelling.
sarisataka
(23,181 posts)We received instructions as to, when we could call a death in the field. Most of it was pretty obvious, such as unsurvivable trauma to the body rigor mortis...
One thing we were instructed, however, is in the case of a child drowning, it is never to be called. Nor is CPR to be stopped. You go as long as you physically can or until you can get the child to higher level of care. There are too many instances of a child drowning, especially in cold water. Which if I recall, is only sixty degrees fahrenheit or lower, but they have come back long after there should be any hope of survival.