Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nevilledog

(53,230 posts)
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:38 PM Tuesday

The 'now they're going to find out' argument is flawed

https://www.editorialboard.com/the-now-theyre-going-to-find-out-argument-is-flawed/


There’s an argument I want to discuss. It goes something like this: Donald Trump’s policies are going to alienate some of the people who voted for him. To be sure, many of them wanted something done about the economy. Prices were too damn high. But they didn’t sign up for tariffs, deportations and cuts to social services, like food stamps.

As a liberal pundit put it, Trump seems poised to follow through with that policy agenda, though going through with it is “political suicide.”

My question is why.

Why are we expecting so much from Trump voters? I’m not making a distinction between his base and those who chose to go along for the ride. I mean all of his supporters, and I’m asking: Why should we place our democratic faith, and the future of the republic, in their hands?

It’s not like Trump had an agenda to bring down the cost of living. All he said was “Make America Great Again.” Deport “illegals.” Suppress transgender rights. Beat down weak and marginalized folks. Voilà!

His one economic plan was tariffs. A tax on imported goods from China and elsewhere will raise prices on everything, not just imports, as retailers will price-gouge under cover of inflation. Tariffs are the opposite of what you do to reduce costs. And that’s why he lied. Trump said nations would pay the tax, not companies bringing goods in.

His voters chose to believe him.

*snip*
40 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The 'now they're going to find out' argument is flawed (Original Post) Nevilledog Tuesday OP
.... Diamond_Dog Tuesday #1
Mexico Will Pay For It! Mr.Bee Tuesday #18
Trump voters won't learn dlk Tuesday #2
The entire country will become Alabama. al_liberal Tuesday #3
Google and read about . . . AverageOldGuy Tuesday #37
K&R Solly Mack Tuesday #4
When they cut out food stamps and social security and medicaid Tribetime Tuesday #5
Without realizing Mr.Bee Tuesday #16
They won't cut SS progressoid Tuesday #29
I'm not sure that they won't cut markodochartaigh Tuesday #30
I'm afraid this is probably right. yardwork Tuesday #6
yep. I heard that happens in Texas. GOP runs everything but still blame democrats when stuff goes badly BlueWaveNeverEnd Tuesday #10
There is always a scapegoat newdeal2 Tuesday #36
It's not that now they're going to find out sakabatou Tuesday #7
Every dumb Trump move will come with a healthy dose of... lame54 Tuesday #8
Plus the MSM is not going to report anything negative Dan Tuesday #9
THIS live love laugh Tuesday #24
They will blame the "liberals" for everything Cosmocat Tuesday #11
Even with their trifecta. Even though liberals lost. They're constitutionally incapable of taking responsibility when ancianita Tuesday #14
I guess that means they'll be suffering happily... ananda Tuesday #12
His voters paid no attention to the NEWS, elleng Tuesday #13
To me, it's simple, the MAGA crowd voted on RACE over their own interests. They loved trumps talk of iluvtennis Tuesday #15
If that is true, why did he get the votes of a majority of Hispanic men? totodeinhere Tuesday #21
Hispanic men, some not all, are machismo. Bluethroughu Tuesday #25
And so are some black men. I have three voters who are misogynistic and voted for TSF. Also, there are iluvtennis 19 hrs ago #40
Personally Mr.Bee Tuesday #17
I want to do the same Ollie Garkie Tuesday #19
Buy it before January 20th. Mr.Bee Tuesday #22
Go get it now! Bluethroughu Tuesday #26
Trump will be a lame duck the moment he takes office. totodeinhere Tuesday #20
Trump voters don't vote for policies. Trying to sell them on policies will fail. paulkienitz Tuesday #23
It's been said that the average American isn't that smart and half the NoMoreRepugs Tuesday #27
It's not about expecting Trump voters to change. W_HAMILTON Tuesday #28
Just watched this and all I kept thinking about was maga kerouac2 Tuesday #31
Because what his voters hear on Fox News and Newsmax, etc. oldmanlynn Tuesday #32
Butt... Fox Nooze says everything is fine Kalifornia9 Tuesday #33
"Why are we expecting so much from Trump voters?" AverageOldGuy Tuesday #34
Recommended. H2O Man Tuesday #35
Just because a fool finds out doesn't mean they learn anything. TheKentuckian Yesterday #38
Wait till he eliminates the National Labor Relations Board Blue Full Moon 22 hrs ago #39

al_liberal

(429 posts)
3. The entire country will become Alabama.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:54 PM
Tuesday

Where nobody cares if they don’t have anything so long as minorities aren’t getting anything either. When integration came to AL they filled in all of the public swimming pools rather than share them with “those” people.

AverageOldGuy

(2,052 posts)
37. Google and read about . . .
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 11:53 PM
Tuesday

. . . the "segregation academies" that are alive and doing quite well in most of the Southern states.

In my native county of Wilkinson County, MS, there are two "segregation academies" -- Centreville Christian Academy and Wilkinson County Christian Academy -- while the local and county school systems are 100% Black. At the "Christian academies" there are usually 1, 2, 3, 4 black faces -- all of whom are the star quarterback or running back or track star.

Back in late 1990's, when public schools in the South were grudgingly integrating, the "segregation academies" were mostly up to 8th grade after which White kids had to go to school with "those people." Wife's cousin and his family visited us with a teenaged daughter who was going to -- in September -- move out of her lily White school into an integrated public high school. This was the sole topic of conversation from them!!! The girl waked up every morning vomiting because she was so terrified of starting school in the fall with "those people." Damn but a few years later she moved to Atlanta and married one of those people!!!!!!!!!!!! When her cousin called my wife in tears because his daughter was marrying one of those people, my wife laughed her ass off. To this day, wife's cousin does not allow his daughter, her Black husband, or their kids to visit; sends them no Christmas gifts; does not recognize any of their birthdays. He calls my wife about once a month -- she always inquires about the daughter and her Black husband and family, pisses off her cousin, he hangs up. Fuck him.

progressoid

(50,743 posts)
29. They won't cut SS
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 11:08 PM
Tuesday

But look for plans for privatization of the management of SS.

They did that with Medicaid in IA and other states. Look for more of that bullshit.

markodochartaigh

(2,056 posts)
30. I'm not sure that they won't cut
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 11:17 PM
Tuesday

Social Security. Reagan did, to public employees with a pension who had also worked in jobs covered by Social Security. And during Trump's last term he suspended the payroll tax which funds Social Security for several months.

BlueWaveNeverEnd

(10,197 posts)
10. yep. I heard that happens in Texas. GOP runs everything but still blame democrats when stuff goes badly
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:01 PM
Tuesday

sakabatou

(43,041 posts)
7. It's not that now they're going to find out
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:57 PM
Tuesday

It's just that even with all the warning signs, the leopard will eat their faces.

lame54

(36,881 posts)
8. Every dumb Trump move will come with a healthy dose of...
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 08:58 PM
Tuesday

It's all the dems fault

And his followers will swallow it whole

Dan

(4,095 posts)
9. Plus the MSM is not going to report anything negative
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:01 PM
Tuesday

About Trump, imagine all of them FOX-lite. Then the social media controlled by MUSK, there truth will be revealed what MUSK wants them to know.

So, when all your sources of information are suspect - what is truth, what is a lie? Critical Thinking will be challenged by the lack of objective information.

We are entering the dark ages.

Cosmocat

(14,959 posts)
11. They will blame the "liberals" for everything
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:03 PM
Tuesday

That they do or what comes from it, and everyone who voted for him will be perfectly fine with it.

ancianita

(38,514 posts)
14. Even with their trifecta. Even though liberals lost. They're constitutionally incapable of taking responsibility when
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:49 PM
Tuesday

they slip-shod their way through governing. Because they're pwn3d tools .

ananda

(30,812 posts)
12. I guess that means they'll be suffering happily...
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:04 PM
Tuesday

knowing that their savior must mean well and just
wants them to be martyrs for the cause.

iluvtennis

(20,847 posts)
15. To me, it's simple, the MAGA crowd voted on RACE over their own interests. They loved trumps talk of
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 09:55 PM
Tuesday

stomping all over black/brown people, LGBTQ folks, Muslims, Jews, etc, etc. That's why they voted for DonOLD as he promised them that white supremacy would reign in America

totodeinhere

(13,301 posts)
21. If that is true, why did he get the votes of a majority of Hispanic men?
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:15 PM
Tuesday

And why did he increase his support among black men?

Bluethroughu

(5,758 posts)
25. Hispanic men, some not all, are machismo.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:43 PM
Tuesday

My husband is not, but his dad and brothers are, and voted for trump.

We do not talk to them, it is futile.

iluvtennis

(20,847 posts)
40. And so are some black men. I have three voters who are misogynistic and voted for TSF. Also, there are
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 10:54 AM
19 hrs ago

many minorities who think that MAGA white supremacy won't apply to them. I know that sounds crazy, but based on my life experiences I've observed it to be true.

Mr.Bee

(351 posts)
17. Personally
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:02 PM
Tuesday
I plan to buy as little as possible over the next four years. No splurging, no Amazon, no Ebay. Necessities only.

Mr.Bee

(351 posts)
22. Buy it before January 20th.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:20 PM
Tuesday

Just checked Google- Laptops at $99, and some under. In 2016 I bought two of those Nextbooks for $99 each, come in real handy during power outages.

totodeinhere

(13,301 posts)
20. Trump will be a lame duck the moment he takes office.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:12 PM
Tuesday

So I don't think he cares. All he cares about is blowing up the government and staying out of jail. It looks like due to the rank stupidity of so many American voters he will accomplish both.

NoMoreRepugs

(10,513 posts)
27. It's been said that the average American isn't that smart and half the
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:55 PM
Tuesday

country is below that. To expect self awareness from loons is a folly.

W_HAMILTON

(8,489 posts)
28. It's not about expecting Trump voters to change.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 10:58 PM
Tuesday

It's about the Biden coalition of voters realizing once again what some of them all too easily forgot about the last Trump administration.

oldmanlynn

(388 posts)
32. Because what his voters hear on Fox News and Newsmax, etc.
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 11:24 PM
Tuesday

Is not reality but misinformation. Fox News keeps their audience in the dark and continues to push rage. Republicans and Russians use similar tactics.

AverageOldGuy

(2,052 posts)
34. "Why are we expecting so much from Trump voters?"
Tue Nov 19, 2024, 11:42 PM
Tuesday

Because we Democrats tend to view the world through rose-colored glasses -- we think "it can't be that bad," "MAGAts will see the light and vote for Democrats in 2026," "he can't damage the foundations of America," "we will clean house in 2026." -- and similar self-deceptive horseshit.

Which is why I have turned off CNN and MSNBC -- they have now joined the long line of those just waiting to kiss Trump's ass and get his blessing.

I ordered, they arrived today, and I'm putting them on all my vehicles -- decals that read "FDT" -- "Fuck Donald Trump." Decal of Calvin pissing on Trump for my truck's rear window (just below my decals that read "Vietnam Vet," "Ranger," "Airborne," "US Army Retired." bumper stickers that read "Not My President" and "Don't Blame Me, I Voted for Harris."

I've already been confronted by some MAGAts at the grocery and hardware stores in my little red rural VA county. After they raved and gloated for a few minutes, I told them to fuck off. Meanwhile, I'm carrying concealed -- Sig Sauer P365.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The 'now they're going to...